Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Quote-start

Stirring and Sublime

Quote-end

5 Apr 13th, 2006 

24 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Wonderful transcriptions of JS Bach's majestic music; sensitive, tender, vivacious, effortless and fluid playing .

Disadvantages:
Nil .

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

Value for Money

zerbine28

zerbine28

About me:

Member since:15.03.2003

Reviews:105

Members who trust:66

Her latest CD from EMI Classics, ‘Bach/Works for Trumpet’, already tops zerbine28's list for Classical CD of the Year. (I know, I know, it's only April as I post this, but that's how strongly I feel about this recording.)

Readers, if you please, do welcome young British trumpet player Alison Balsom, who now joins the ranks of Mssrs Miles Davis and Herb Alpert in my teeny-tiny list of favourite trumpeters. No, I never heard of her, either, before yesterday, when I first sampled her CD at the local Borders book and music shop.

Released just this past January, the CD is an absolute stunner. The title is a little misleading, because Johann Sebastian Bach never wrote pieces specifically for the instrument (discounting the Brandenburg Concerto No. 2, of course). Besides which, the ‘trumpet’ in Bach’s time was nothing like the valved species familiar to us today. The antique version must have been hell to play, since it depended solely on lip control to create any melodic variation, especially in the upper register. All of which is totally irrelevant to Alison Balsom, who uses the modern valved trumpet (piccolo and C types) to play these works of Baroque magnificence. (Do I hear lamentation from the period instrument purists? Oh, pshaw.)

The pieces on this album were arranged and transcribed, or co-arranged and co-transcribed by Ms Balsom herself from works for the keyboard, cello, oboe, flute, voice, etc. Transcription seems to come easily to her: so natural do the works of Bach sound on the trumpet, you’d think they were written especially for it. The trumpet repertoire is rather thin on the classical side of things, and surely, Bach himself would have welcomed these transcriptions. He often adapted his own music for a variety of instruments.

Well, I’m speechless with astonishment (but not wholly so, as you can see) at Ms Balsom’s extraordinary technique. Her unwavering tone is beautifully realised and ranges from mellow to piercing, played thus as the piece requires. It is precise and clean, but far from colourless and sterile. Her runs have a delightful fluidity that evokes a jazz-like sense of ease, as one hears, for instance, on the Gigue from Partita No. 3. She dashes off those thrilling but infernal Baroque embellishments (trills, mordents, grace notes) with assuredness and poise. Needless to say (but I’ll say it anyway), the virtuosic passages become mere child’s play for this fantastic trumpeter. With their intricacy and complexity, Baroque pieces are the devil to muster (and master) on any musical device, but the trumpet makes special demands on the player's breathing that the other plucked, hammered and bowed instruments do not. Being such a wimp at breath-holding and control myself, I listen amazed at Ms Balsom's sustained breaths on parts that run on without pause, such as those on the Allegro from the Vivaldi-inspired Concerto in D.

The music on 'Works for Trumpet' occasionally ascends to such heights of sublimity that leave me on the verge of tears. Such heavenly ecstasy can be experienced with the Largo of the Concerto in C Minor (after Marcello) and the Adagio of the Concerto in D (after Vivaldi), which have Ms Balsom's reflective trumpet seeming all alone in a bittersweet melancholy, the companion organ sounding so hushed and distant.

With the help of other, equally superb musicians, the chamber works become ensemble pieces of Baroque perfection. Ms Balsom’s partners in crime include Colm Carey on the organ, Alistair Ross on the harpsichord and chamber organ, Alina Ibragimova on the violin (herself a member, like Alison Balsom, of the BBC's 'New Generation Artists' - see below), and Mark Caudle on the viola da gamba (forerunner of the modern violoncello). Be it on the open, airy and colourful organ, the raspy violin, or the crystalline, chime-like harpsichord, the music is perfectly counterbalanced by the bold, metallic trumpet providing contrapuntal melody. Truth to tell, I’m usually ready to commit a few small murders if forced to listen to more than a few minutes of purely organ or harpsichord music. The addition of trumpets changes all that – especially when they're played with such vivacity, tenderness and sensitivity as these are – then I turn into a harmless, non-homicidal and blissfully happy Bachmaniac.

For a glimpse of pure trumpet heaven, there’s the lively, minor-key Badinerie, lifted from the Orchestral Suite No. 2 (originally written for solo flute and strings), on which Ms Balsom plays a solo piccolo trumpet (the highest-pitched one). And if you’re seeking some lovely pathos to enjoy, there’s the Agnus Dei from the Mass in B minor. Here the trumpet’s mournfulness is no less affecting than the original version with voice, supplemented as it is with textural harmonic counterpoint from the violin, organ and viola da gamba.

But really, mere words still fail me in this attempt to capture the all-around excellence of this disc. Go and listen to the music for yourself. Following are a few of the relevant web pages that have links for audio samples (need RealPlayer or Windows Media Player to run):

http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/B000CNEO1G/qid=1144961414/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8_xs_ap_i1_xgl/202-6907497-5376657

http://music.barnesandnoble.com/search/product.asp?z=y&PWB=1&EAN=724355804723

http://www.cduniverse.com/search/xx/music/pid/7008731/a/Bach:+Works+for+Trumpet+%2F+Alison+Balsom,+et+al.htm


Well, you can't say you weren't warned: keep your eye (and ear) on Alison Balsom, trumpeter extraordinaire. She has yet to make a splash on this side of the pond, but audiences in the UK and the rest of Europe, South America, the Middle East and Japan have been more fortunately acquainted with Ms Balsom for some years now. I can only hope to catch a live performance in this country - that is, if she ever plans to return to the USA. Ms Balsom has already had her US debut, performing just this January 2006 with the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra (Milwaukee? Not New York City and Carnegie Hall? How did they get to be so lucky in Wisconsin! Methinks Ms Balsom needs a better agent/promoter, no?!).

FINAL VERDICT: I give this disc an unqualified, insanely enthusiastic recommendation with all thumbs and great toes up, for all lovers of Bach and/or the trumpet. Total, absolute must-have recording.


[For more complete background info on Alison Balsom, please scroll down the page to the BBC Radio 3 article.]


CD DETAILS:

BACH: WORKS FOR TRUMPET

Alison Balsom

EMI Classics

5 58047 2 (CD) / 5 58047 5

Concerto in D Major (after Vivaldi) BWV 972:
1 Allegro
2 Adagio
3 Allegro Assai
4 Sarabande (from Cello Suite No.2 BWV 1008)
5 Gigue (from Cello Suite No.2 BWV 1008)
6 Aria Variata in A Minor (Italian Variations) BWV 989
7 Gigue from Violin Partita no 3. BWV1006
Trio Sonata in C Major BWV 529
8 Allegro
9 Largo
10 Allegro
Concerto in C minor (after Marcello) BWV 974:
11 Allegro
12 Largo
13 Presto
14 Bist du bei mir (from Anna Magdalena Notebook BWV 508)
Concerto in A major (transposed to C Major) BWV 1055:
15 Allegro
16 Larghetto
17 Allegro ma non tanto
18 Badinerie from Orchestral Suite no.2 BWV 1067
19 Agnus Dei from Mass in B minor BWV 232

Performers:
Alison Balsom (trumpets), Colm Carey (organ), Alina Ibragimova (violin), Alistair Ross (harpsichord & chamber organ), Mark Caudle (viola da gamba)

Total running time: 71' 31"

List Price:
$16.98
GBP13.99
(Of course, it can easily be had for less on many online stores. Just Google the disc name and artist.)

~~~~~~~~~~~

The following information was taken from the BBC Radio 3’s webpages on the ‘New Generation Artists’ series:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio3/classical/newgenerations/balsom.shtml

Alison Balsom (trumpet)

Nationality: British

Places of study and teachers:
Guildhall School of Music and Drama and the Paris Conservatoire, graduating in 2001 with First Class Honours. Recent studies with Håkan Hardenberger.

Prizes/Accolades:
1998 - concerto finalist in the BBC Young Musicians Competition and in 2000 won the prize for the 'Most Beautiful Sound' at the Maurice André International Trumpet Competition in Paris. Alison was the first ever brass player to be represented by the Young Concert Artists Trust London, 2001-4.

Recent performances include:
The premiere of a special commission by BBC Radio 3 and the Royal Philharmonic Society from Django Bates.

Performances with the Stuttgart Radio Symphony with Sir Roger Norrington, Bamberg Symphony with Mikko Franck, Munich Chamber Orchestra with Christoph Poppen, the BBC Proms, and the Barbican's Mostly Mozart Festival. Alison performs regularly with the London Chamber Orchestra.

Whilst represented by the Young Artists Concert Trust, Alison caught the ear of EMI Classics, who released her debut CD in 2002 and have recently renewed their commitment with an exclusive three disc contract. Her next CD is an all-Bach programme (released September 2005 [actually in January 2006 - this is the self-same CD reviewed above]).


 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Beethoven: Complete Symphonies

Beethoven: Complete Symphonies

5CD(s) - Label:Karajan Anniversary Collection - Distributor:EMI - Released:04/02/2008 - 5099951586324

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 10.88

Béjart: Nutcracker

Béjart: Nutcracker

1CD(s) - Label:EMI Classics - Distributor:EMI - Released:24/11/2008 - 5099921658693

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 6.69

The Magic Flute of James Galway

The Magic Flute of James Galway

1CD(s) - Label:Gold Seal - Distributor:BMG UK - Run Time:1 hour 48 minutes - ADD - Released:06/1992 - 35626091828

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 4.98

Karajan - Complete EMI Recordings Vol 2: Opera & Choral

Karajan - Complete EMI Recordings Vol 2: Opera & Choral

72CD(s) - Label:Karajan Anniversary Collection - Distributor:EMI - Released:04/02/2008 - 5099951197322

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 81.98

England, My England

England, My England

2CD(s) - Label:EMI Classics - Distributor:EMI - Released:06/07/2009 - 5099922894403

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 8.98

Handel: Rinaldo

Handel: Rinaldo

2CD(s) - Label:ArtHaus Musik - Distributor:Select - Run Time:4 hours 37 minutes - DDD - Released:03/03/2003 - 4006680103884

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 24.93

Comments about this review »

No_name 15.04.2006 21:15

Bach has always been my favourite 'traditional' classical composer (though I remember you were never overly impressed with Philip Glass, he's still my favourite overall - sorry ;oP), but I', never too sure what to get of his as his range of work is so vast (and I'm so choosy). This sounds like something to venture out and attempt. Another fine musical addition to the ranks.

patriciat 15.04.2006 15:27

I know absolutely nothing about trumpet playing but your enthusiasm really came across and you made it sound exciting. Pat.t x

berlioz 14.04.2006 17:15

There's a lot of Bach going around Ciao at the moment it seems. If it helps I can lend my 10 fingers and toes too to give you a smacking 20 for a recommendation (with the understanding that I enjoy Telemann the best of all)... Berli

Compare prices for Bach: Works for Trumpet »

1 offer for Bach: Works for Trumpet   sorted by: Price 




Are you the manufacturer / provider of Bach: Works for Trumpet? Click here