Banba - Clannad

Banba - Clannad > Reviews > Bright stars piercing through a cloudy sky.

1 CD(s) - Irish - Label: RCA - Distributor: Sony BMG/Arvato Services - Released: 08/1996 - 743211396127 more

Overall user rating Banba - Clannad 1 review | Write a review | Add product to list





Please wait ....
Rate this product:  
 
All Banba - Clannad reviews
Bright stars piercing through a cloudy sky.
A review by PDS1 on Banba - Clannad
December 29th, 2005


Author's product rating:   Banba - Clannad - rated by PDS1

Originality Definitely a cut above the rest 
Lyrics Thought-provoking 
Quality and consistency of tracks A couple of weak links 
Value for Money Good 

Advantages: At best, inspirational, haunting and atmospheric
Disadvantages: At worst, just pleasant background music

Recommend to potential buyers: yes 

Full review
The front cover of the CD shows the band, cloaked and hooded, standing solemnly on a bleak hilltop, strongly suggestive that they've returned to their spooky old roots!

Lead singer Maire Brennan has one of the most pure glorious Celtic voices I've ever heard, which she puts into immediate and awesome effect on "Na Laethe Bhi", the opening track of what, at first, sounds a typically uncompromising album. The band entwine their cold, ghostly harmonies, and a huge piercing whistle suddenly glides, mighty, alongside Maire's powerful icy vocals. Entirely devoid of beat or rhythm, this is a genuine Celtic experience if ever I heard one!

"Banba Oir" introduces an elusive, enticing rhythm. Melody and soft vocals merge together in a strange haunting incantation. It's a thoughtful and chilling dance; you can imagine leprechauns and other preternatural beings dancing round an enchanted green fire. ( In fact, come to think of it, this is great inspiring music to write stories to! Ideal atmospheric backdrop...)

The enchantment fades somewhat now, and the album become far more toned down and earthly. No more wonderful Gaelic chants for a while. "There For You" (rather dully) explores the ups and downs of a human relationship. The soft drum machine and piping sax don't really evoke much sense of drama.

"Mystery Game" quietly describes a spirit of adventure and longing. It has a slow tick-tock beat and brings with it a disappointing sense, after the first couple of blinders, that things have come off the boil a bit. Lyrically, too, it seems leaden and uninspired.

The next track "Struggle" raises the game slightly - the band's optimism shines through in a floating ode about shooting and falling stars, setting the brightness of otherworldy objects against the mundane. Maire's voice rises and falls with a dramatic guitar, but I'm left unsatisfied. Her beautiful vocals seem more suited to Celtic purity than quasi-pop.

"I Will Find You" restores the mystery and menace of the earliest tracks on the album. It begins with a low growling chord and clicking triffids! Maire's voice is cold and comfortless, angry and unearthly. The whole thing is put over powerfully as an ancient blood-oath of vengeance, with a scary Gaelic chorus and low throbbing drumbeats added to grim effect. "Wherever you are, I will find you, if it takes a thousand years." Woooh, don't go to bed just after this...

Slipping down a gear again, "Soul Searcher" falls into the realms of a pleasant ballad, this time lead by male vocalist Cieran Brennan. Nice, lilting guitars, but doesn't rise to greatness and dwindles a little too easily into background music.

The next, "Ca De Sin Do'n Te Sin" (spelling?) is a full-on Celtic folkish belter. Its effortless simplicity led to me having a tap at my own keyboard along with the music. Entirely unsurprised to learn that it is in a minor key! Again, it's entirely sung in haunting Gaelic, and has the cadence of ominous poetry. Sunk in a brooding gloom, it seems to conjure up images of old-fashioned stagecoaches trundling across a a foggy moor, lanterns and mysterious beings moving through the mist. Well, that's my mental picture anyway!

"The Other Side" is another optimistic, but far more worldly, effort about looking for your life and dreams. Oh dear, it's nice, but sounds a bit trite! It thrums and runs successfully enough, but merges unmemorably into the sameness of some of the other weaker tracks.

Floating, shimmering guitar waltz "Sunset Dreams" puts me in mind of a soundtrack to a fantasy film or fairy tale. Great stuff for drifting off into a world of one's own. (Nothing wrong with that!)

The finale, in true Clannad tradition, is entirely without vocals. Flutes, hovering synths and a softly-plucked mandolin unite in the dreamy but slightly over-long ballad "A Gentle Place". Close your eyes, and your own gentle place could be wherever you wanted it to be.

In all, the album "Banba" is not flawless. There are times when I'm slightly put off by the corniness of the lryics; notwithstanding the kind finale, there's a tenacious cold feeling almost throughout the whole thing - for the most part. Don't expect to be comforted or soothed. This, on the other hand, could equally be seen as a strength. It really is capable of taking the imagination to all sorts of new places. As an introduction to Clannad, it's probably not ideal - better to buy their Greatest Hits collection "Past Present". For someone really into the band, or perhaps looking to get rather spooked out, maybe give this a try!

I first listened to this album at a friend's house, and it won me over, though not without a few reservations. After that, I easily picked up my copy on an Internet auction site - I'm sure you know where to go! I've never regretted it, even if only for the four wonders I've mentioned above.

So:

Chilled? Not exactly; it's too intense for that.

Lyrically sublime? Well, no, not always.

Mysterious, folkish and magical? Oh yes, at its best, it definitely fits that description!


 
Write your own review




More details
How does it compare to the artist's other releases Good 
How does it rate alongside the competition Good 
Cover / Inlay Design and Content Good 

Evaluate this review
How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?
Rating guidelines

   

Comments on this review
More options
All Banba - Clannad reviews

Related offers for Banba - Clannad

Related offers for Banba - Clannad    
 
Amazon UK
651 Ratings
Amazon UK
Find "Banba - Clannad" New and Used on Amazon. Free UK Delivery on orders over £25.
Amazon UK

Products you might be interested in
20 Great Irish Drinking Songs (Whiskey In The Jar) - Various Artists

1 CD(s) - Irish - Label: Music - Distributor: Delta Music/Arvato Services - Released: 07/07/2003 - 4006408063964

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 0.98

Best Of The Dubliners, The - Dubliners (The)Best Of The Dubliners, The - Dubliners (The)

3 CD(s) - Irish - Label: EMI Catalogue - Distributor: EMI - Released: 18/08/2003 - 724358448825

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 4.59

McCormack Songs Vol.1 - John McCormackMcCormack Songs Vol.1 - John McCormack

1 CD(s) - Irish - Label: Naxos Nostalgia - Distributor: Select - Released: 02/10/2000 - 636943250426

 1 review

Buy now for only £ 3.90

Greece - Music For A Greek Wedding - Various Artists

1 CD(s) - World Music - Label: Hallmark - Distributor: Pickwick - Released: 25/11/2002 - 5050457510329

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 1.72

Nouvelle Vague Vol.1 - Nouvelle VagueNouvelle Vague Vol.1 - Nouvelle Vague

1 CD(s) - Bossa Nova - Label: Peacefrog - Distributor: PIAS UK/Sony DADC - Released: 09/08/2004 - 689781205127

 4 reviews

Buy now for only £ 5.65

Voyage - Christy MooreVoyage - Christy Moore

1 CD(s) - Irish - Label: WEA - Distributor: Cinram Logistics - Released: 05/03/2007 - 22924615627

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 2.97




Are you the manufacturer / provider of Banba - Clannad? Click here