Back after a long absence, in between other writing and musical activities.
Back after a long absence, in between other writing and musical activities.
Member since:13.07.2000
Reviews:262
Members who trust:48
When first released, 'The Beatles', generally known to posterity as the 'White Album' after its stark white packaging, seemed simply baffling. Apart from Bob Dylan's 'Blonde on Blonde', it was the first rock double album, and there was something pretty daunting about the sprawling collection of 30 tracks to digest at once. Numerous other acts have done the same since, but in 1968 it was not the norm.
However, maybe that's one of the most fascinating things about it. It's the least focused album they ever recorded, more like a scrapbook in which they sandwiched the real goodies with a collection of shorter tracks which might be seen as demos or unfinished ideas by one or two members of the group (like McCartney's 53-seconds-long 'Wild Honey Pie'), and a few highly dispensable items which suggest that quality control was giving way to self-indulgence.
Some three and a half decades later, its legendary status is assured. Diehard Beatles fans think it's probably the best thing they ever recorded, and regard any criticism of it as heresy, while others label it monumental self-indulgence and agree with producer George Martin that it should have been pared down to a single album. What's beyond doubt is that it anticipates the end of the group who were becoming four solo artists, sometimes working as session musicians on each others' songs. Sometimes they didn't bother, as they were finding it increasingly difficult to get on with each other on a personal and professional level. The Beatles were beginning to disintegrate, and the composing credit 'Lennon/McCartney' which accompanied all songs written by one or other was transparently false. In fact, several tracks feature only two or three Beatles.
It would be easy to write an entire book about the album. I won't bother - others, like journalist David Quantick, have done it already - and I'll spare you
a complete track-by-track dissection, as you may have other things to do in the next six months. An overview, looking at contributions by each member, will suffice.
Paul McCartney had more or less assumed leadership of the group by now, as John Lennon was starting to lose interest. On the whole, Paul's songs are the best. 'Back in the USSR' is more than a send-up of the Beach Boys with its vocal harmonies, it rocks with more grit than the surfin' boys could ever manage. (BB Mike Love later claimed to have had a hand in writing the song, though nobody else backs him up). It's also one of several tracks on which the group are a trio, as Ringo Starr was fed up with Paul's put-downs and walked out for a couple of weeks, leaving the latter to play drums on it. 'Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da' is one of those songs that has always divided fans. One of the first white reggae tracks, recorded long before reggae became hip, some love it while others think it unbearably twee and cheesy. I like it myself, though I preferred a version by the Marmalade, who took it to No. 1 early in 1969.
'Blackbird', a solo performance which he sings to the accompaniment of a lightly-picked acoustic guitar (and some birdsong effects from the tape library) is a nice light folksy interlude. 'Honey Pie' is a 20s/30s jazz pastiche, almost straight out of a television costume drama soundtrack, a music hall-style piece that could have sounded unbearably corny in the wrong hands. It says much for his versatility that the same man is responsible for the screaming heavy metal of 'Helter Skelter' - their original recording was a marathon which included a 10-minute guitar solo (Led Beateppelin, anyone?) - and the riff-driven 'Birthday', heavily influenced by Little Richard - you can almost hear the echoes of 'Good Golly Miss Molly' on this one.
In my view, John Lennon's songs are nowhere near as good. By this time he had his head in avant-garde territory (I nearly said he had his head in Yoko Ono, but ...) and being a Beatle had become a chore.
It shows. 'Glass Onion' is little more than an in-joke with references to Paul really being the Walrus he sang about in 'I Am The Walrus' (c'mon, John, how many listeners really care'). 'I'm So Tired' is a dirge about boredom - and the spirit of boredom proved infectious, as it's hardly riveting listening. Despite the ugly cracked quality of his voice, 'Yer Blues' is an improvement, a stab at early Fleetwood Mac territory with one or two interesting switches in rhythm, though the version he played on the Rolling Stones Rock'n'Roll Circus with Eric Clapton and Keith Richard is better.
'Happiness Is a Warm Gun', 'The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill' and 'Sexy Sadie' sound forced and uninspired, and the 9-minute sound collage of 'Revolution No. 9' is pretentious nonsense. (It could have been worse - he also made an album which reputedly consisted of nothing but his and Yoko Ono's heartbeats - "I'm a Beatle, I can release rubbish if I want to.")
His best songs are the ballads, 'Dear Prudence' and 'Julia'. The closing track 'Goodnight' is too MOR; maybe he just wanted to prove he could beat Paul at his own game. Interestingly Ringo Starr sings the latter to orchestral accompaniment, while none of the other three do so much as shake a tambourine.
George Harrison was allowed four songs this time round. Even if the guitar solo on 'While My Guitar Gently Weeps' was played by Eric Clapton (uncredited at the time for contractual reasons), it's still one of the highlights of the album. 'Piggies' is a bit of a joke - whether silly or amusing depends on your point of view. 'Long Long Long' sounds ethereal and bland on first listen, but the ambient charm breaks through after a few plays. 'Savoy Truffle' is amusing if a shade trite. The lyrics may be little more than a steal off a chocolate box, but the guitar and saxophone work lay down a blueprint for what was to become the characteristic Harrison solo sound later on.
For the first time, Ringo Starr even gets to contribute a composition. He had written 'Don't Pass Me By' a few years earlier, but claimed the rest of the group all made fun of it and refused to consider recording it. Like the better-known 'Octopus Garden', his song on the subsequent 'Abbey Road', its naïve singalong cheeriness and jaunty hoedown fiddle offer a bit of light relief. Not that the rest of the group joined in - only Paul and session violinist Jack Fallon accompanied the drummer.
Like the rest of their catalogue, the White Album is an expensive item that's unlikely to be issued at budget price, though cheaper copies can sometimes be found in megastore sales. But with 93 minutes playing time, it's better value for money than most of the single albums (even if you take out the almost unlistenable 'Revolution No. 9'). The most commonly found version on CD is the double jewel case version, though a 30th anniversary edition was issued in a cardboard sleeve as a miniature replica of the original album complete with a mini-poster and the four colour postcards that accompanied the initial release.
And if that's not enough, for those of you who still collect vinyl and must have everything (and there are Beatles fans who must), the record originally came out in both mono and stereo, with very different mixes on some tracks in order to lure the affluent completist. Do you really need to know about the 1978 white vinyl limited edition? Ahem, thought not..
Four stars might be a little generous. When it's good it's terrific, but it has plenty of dross which makes one grateful for the Skip button. Frankly I reckon it's rather more highly regarded in the group's back catalogue than it deserves. It wouldn't be my recommendation to anyone who's never listened to the Beatles before and wonders what all the fuss was about. But for the interested and intrigued, it's certainly worth having.
Prices vary widely. Online, the best buy looks like CD-WOW (£16.99, with free delivery worldwide). Comapre that with Amazon (£23.99), or MVC, WH Smith (£25.99), which may or may not have a delivery charge on top. £25 seems to be the standard high street price, barring sales as suggested above. Last time I checked eBay, there were around 50 copies (CD and vinyl) for auction, bid prices from £5 to £80, depending on condition and collectability status. To list the number of variations which exist (for example, the rare vinyl edition with a sleeve that opens at the top instead of the side...you get the picture?) would easily double the length of this review!
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
I bought this when it first came out....A double album as you say was unheard of then...It was part of my youth and I still like a lot of the stuff on it......Amazing piece of writing and I am sure every Beatles fan would enjoy it.....Hence a well deserved with love from " E to You " ( sic ).......Roy
danielse 24.11.2004 12:32
I actually listen to more of this with my kids now than I do with the other albums. They respond to Bungalow Bill and Ob La Di and I sing Goodnight to my daughter in bed almost every evening hearing the strings playing in my head. If every band produced a cracking-up album as great as this...
This is not a new idea: in 2001 the English label Indigo produced a collection of Beatles ... more
songs by British and American blues artists. That was patchy, and so is this. The Beatles' heavy-handed treatment of "Why Don't We Do It in the Road?" was intende...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery Availability: Temporarily out of stock. Order now and we'll deliver when available. We'll e-mail you with an estimated delivery date as soon...
This is not a new idea: in 2001 the English label Indigo produced a collection of Beatles ... more
songs by British and American blues artists. That was patchy, and so is this. The Beatles' heavy-handed treatment of "Why Don't We Do It in the Road?" was intende...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Advantages: There's never been, and never will be, anything like it. Some of the greatest rock ever. Disadvantages: Possibly too long to listen to all at once, but still great all the way through.
Advantages: One of the most amazing collections of songs you will ever hear - so varied and exciting Disadvantages: There are some weak links and some songs you do really wonder about...