Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Quote-start

Maybe he should drop out of tha Roc

Quote-end

3 Aug 22nd, 2004 

23 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Masterful Production, Great Eye - Opening Songs and Lyrics, Positive, Introspective, Thought - Provoking

Disadvantages:
Lack of Complex Lyrics, Too Many Skippable Skits, Some Weaker Tracks, Ego - Trip

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

Value for Money

bigdiship-hop

bigdiship-hop

About me:

I'm Big D, from Tampa. I review Hip-Hop passionately. I hope you enjoy my work.

Member since:23.07.2004

Reviews:73

Members who trust:5


To be completely honest, Rocafella Records is one of the most talentless camps in hip-hop. Outside of Ol Dirty Bastard, M.O.P., and sometimes Jay-Z, the label is struggling due to its handful of terrible performers, horrid lyricists, and selfish artists. With overrated artists like Freeway, Beanie Sigel, and Memphis Bleek, backed by awful rappers The Diplomats, and pretty useless up and comers O. Sparxxx and State Property, it seems The Roc is all bark but no bite. Pretty much everything that "The Roc" has put out has been complete garbage. Sadly, even CEO and Acclaimed Rapper Jay-Z's final album, which was hyped up heavily, turned out to be simply another poof on his career.

However, in late 2003, a new artist propped up who could be The Roc's final hope for putting out excellent music. Kanye West was already acclaimed for his work on various Rocafella projects in the past few years, including Jay-Z's last 3 albums, providing some very good beats for Jigga to spit over. His unique blend of high pitched sped-up vocal samples and soulful melodies provide great atmospheres and even make some unlistenable rappers sound enjoyable. Kanye West has decided to move forward and finally drop his debut album, 2004's College Dropout. Though his mic presence isn't neccessarily the most intimidating, Kanye West has proven that he is indeed capable of putting his heart and soul into his music, making it quite powerful, resulting in one of the most anticipated albums of the year. Question is, can Kanye West do the impossible and outshine even his own boss???


Track List & Rating

1. Intro (NOT RATED)
2. We Don't Care (3 1/2 Stars)
3. Graduation Day Skit (NOT RATED)
4. All Falls Down f/ Syleena Johnson (5 Stars)
5. I'll Fly Away Skit (NOT RATED)
6. Spaceship f/ CLG & Consequence (5 Stars)
7. Jesus Walks (4 Stars)
8. Never Let You Down f/ Jay-Z & Saul Williams (5 Stars)
9. Get Em High f/ Common, Talib Kweli (4 Stars)
10. Workout Plan Skit (NOT RATED)
11. The New Workout Plan (0 Stars)
12. Slow Jamz f/ Twista & Jamie Foxx (3 1/2 Stars)
13. Breathe In, Breathe Out f/ Ludacris (0 Stars)
14. School Spirit Skit 1 (NOT RATED)
15. School Spirit (4 Stars)
16. School Spirit Skit 2 (NOT RATED)
17. Lil Jimmy Skit (NOT RATED)
18. Two Words f/ Mos Def, Freeway, and Harlem Boys Choir (3 Stars)
19. Through the Wire (4 Stars)
20. Family Business (4 1/2 Stars)
21. Last Call (4 1/2 Stars)


College Dropout, the most anticipated album of the year, kicks off with "We Don't Care". Kanye West, doubling as producer and emcee for most of the album, comes on here with a relatively nice opening joint. His beat is good, yet, far from perfect. Sadly, the production on this song suffers from having too many things going on in the background. Everything from over-synthesized effects, to soul samples, to jazz, to bass is found here, and to me it sounds rather cluttered and overproduced. Subject Matter and Lyrically, Kanye does an excellent job of explaining his uprising having to do with selling drugs on the streets and living the hard life. Kanye West is pretty adept at creating very personal music about survival, and that is what this track is all about. A Nice Start.

Continuing on the album we have the first true highlight, the very personal "All Falls Down". Kanye West's beat featuring some surprisingly minimalistic elements with bass, backed by some light guitars providing a soft melody. Vocally, Kanye West is joined by Syleena Johnson, who provides the hook and a lot of background vocals. Kanye West successfully adapts his style to street poetry, rapping about people he knew and tribulations he has seen from his own eyes as well as others, reminiscent of true-school hip-hop anthems from the mid 90s. One admittingly clever line of wordplay is: "Couldnt afford a car so she called her daughter Alexis / A Lexus".

As I have said, Kanye West typically strays away from commercialism most of the time and stays in tune with spilling his own guts on wax. Once I type this, immediately "Spaceship" comes to mind (and because its next on the tracklist). Production-wise, we get a nice soulful mix of Kanye-ish production with background vocals by GLC and a handful of well organized instruments. Subject Matter wise, Kanye West gives us an emotionally driven introspective track about the essense of life, leaving the bad times and transversing yourself into the good. Kanye touches on several subjects without staying on just one (which is kind of typical for him). The rapping and singing by both parties is admirably very good. Besides that, Consequence drops by to deliver a seminal, eye-opening verse.

A lot people have made a big deal about "Jesus Walks", and yeah, its got a great concept, but the way it is done is bad to me. The beat is very annoying, the R&B singing isn't neccessary, and the lyrics aren't as eye opening as one would expect. I won't lie though, the song has immensely grown on me probably because it took me a short while to fully understand the message behind this. It's sort of funny to find Kanye West, who is signed to one of the most commercial rap labels, rap about how poisoned hip-hop is due to commercialism and lack of creativity. It's sort of refreshing to hear it, despite Kanye's lack of true rhyme skill. This song definitely grows on you.

The eighth track on the album, "Never Let You Down", finds a newly retired Jay-Z returning to the mic to drop a verse for Kanye. From the onset, you can tell this song is going to have heartfelt production, and that certainly rings true. Using a soulful, bass-inspired beat with violins and an instantly head-bobbing melody, this sets the tone for one of the best songs on the album. The subject matter finds Kanye West rapping about his promises made to his family (specifically his grandmother) and how he has achieved them due to his success. This is a rather good twist on the "rags to riches" type of track, and Jay-Z's verse is actually rather excellent and fitting for this song. Saul Williams gives us an incredible chorus to accompany this great song.

Two of my favorite Underground emcees join Kanye West on "Get Em High". Even though the title may suggest it, this track isn't about weed thankfully. Kanye delivers on the boards with an easy-to-listen-to production effort, with a playful mixture of over-synthesized drums, bass, and light guitar to provide a nice melody. Besides production, Kanye drops a phenomenal opening verse which surprises me because I honestly had no clue he had it in him. His second verse wasn't as good, but it is forgivable. Kweli gets on the mic and spits something which is sadly a far stretch from his hay day in Rawkus Records. The old, anti-commercial Kweli is beginning to die out, however, is not reduced to a clubbish bopper. Kweli drops a pretty short, yet somewhat dope verse to lead the way for Common to spit. Common, being a native of Chicago, Illinois like Kanye, drops the last verse, keeping his poetic and powerful style intact.

The next actual song "The New Workout Plan" is whack. You're probably thinking "Big D... why is the song whack?" Well, just give it one listen and you'll see. Commercial, Clubbish, Bad Beat, Bad Lyrics, Bad Delivery... typically the stuff I don't like that comes out of Rocafella Records. The same holds true for "Breathe In, Breathe Out".

The new hot single hitting the airwaves and television right now is the Twista, Kanye, and Jamie Foxx joint "Slow Jamz". A lot of people confuse this track with being commercial, and granted, it has a lot of commercial like elements, specially by Twista. In my humble opinion, this song is a tribute to old-school slow jams (well it's obvious), and how they seemingly drives women crazy. Jamie Foxx does a nice chorus, and Kanye's opening verse is ill, as well as Twista does his job too. I'm not a fan of triple-cadence rapping unless its Bone Thugs & Harmony, but Twista is admittingly listenable on here as he TRIES to insert melodies in there but at times doesn't quite achieve it. The sped-up Luther Vandross adds new dimensions to an already dope joint.

"Two Words" is a crew joint featuring Freeway, Harlem Boys Choir, and the Mighty Mos Def, who sadly, isn't as mighty. I'm not sure if its the Rocafella influences taking him in, but Mos Def spits ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh... rather bad on here. In fact, it's rare to find Def spit anything lower than 90%, but on here, he resorts to simple rhymes and double syllable rhymes. I mean, i know that Kweli is also losing his skills, but give me a break. Hopefully this change will not last. Freeway drops an admittingly listenable verse (dare I say, better than Def's lyrics), as well as Kanye West's rather good performance when stood up to a heavyweight like Def. Production-wise, the song delivers with a nice jazzy beat strummed with bass, low-key xylophones, and hard drum loops. Not one of West's best beats, but still fitting. However, me being a hardcore fan of Mos Def (i can never forget "Water" and "Hip-Hop"), its very difficult for me to get over his newfound whackness. Hopefully, this is only temporary as I pray that Mos Def's pen hasn't run out of ink just yet (as it seems Kweli's is rather quickly, see above).

The lead single "Through the Wire" soon comes onto the headphones. If you have yet to hear this song on mainstream radio, then it is obvious you are trapped on some sort of other planet. Kanye West delivers a powerful, eye-opening joint where he touches on the topic of his mouth being wired shut due to a car accident he suffered last year. He raps honestly, explaining his trials and tribulations during the ordeal and how those around him had to adapt to the circumstances for those six weeks. Production-wise, the song is excellent, with a great sample which is powerful and energetic. Even though West isn't the greatest songwriter ever and his lyrics aren't as complex as possible, he manages to spill his guts on the pad without beating around the bush, which is commendable. This is a very good lead-single which can appeal to both commercial and underground fans.

"Family Business" and "Last Call" end the album on a high-note. After the well-produced plethora of dope tracks, we get two very conscious, personal joints with great beats, and admittingly good lyrics. Afterwards, he ends the album on a spoken word note, thanking all of those who helped him on his way up. Pretty fitting ending to College Dropout.

What's this? A NON-Commercial Rocafella Album, what is the world coming to! College Dropout has its honest to god brilliant moments, and a lot of whack ones too. This album was honestly not as good, nor as bad as everybody makes it out to be. It's obvious that Kanye worked hard and this album is good at showing off his STILL overrated production skills, and he manages to do it without the need of clubbish anthems and materialistic bullsh*t all over the place. It's rather hard to believe that a producer can outshine a labels CEO, but its honest to god the truth. Kanye hits us with conscious music and well-done compositions. If you have to, Drop out of College to get this one...

Yes, its better than Black Album

3.5 Stars

 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

W, The - Wu-Tang Clan

W, The - Wu-Tang Clan

1 CD(s) - Rap - Label: Loud/Epic - Distributor: Sony Music/Arvato Services - Released: 09/12/2002 - 5099749957626

User reviews (17)

Buy now for only £ 4.98

100 R&B Classics (Parental Advisory) - Various Artists

100 R&B Classics (Parental Advisory) - Various Artists

5 CD(s) - Contemporary R&B - Label: Warner Music TV - Distributor: Cinram Logistics - Released: 22/10/2007 - 5051442490527

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 11.78

Late Registration (Parental Advisory) [PA] - Kanye West

Late Registration (Parental Advisory) [PA] - Kanye West

1 CD(s) - Rap - Label: Roc-A-Fella - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 29/08/2005 - 602498851531

User reviews (13)

Buy now for only £ 3.48

Clubland Classix Vol.1 (The Album Of Your Life) - Various Artists

Clubland Classix Vol.1 (The Album Of Your Life) - Various Artists

3 CD(s) - Dance - Label: Universal Music TV - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 31/03/2008 - 600753075685

User reviews (3)

Buy now for only £ 10.37

Love Songs - 20 Classic Hits - Stevie Wonder

Love Songs - 20 Classic Hits - Stevie Wonder

1 CD(s) - R&B - Label: Motown - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 01/1993 - 731453003729

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 4.98

Essential R&B - The Love Collection - Various Artists

Essential R&B - The Love Collection - Various Artists

2 CD(s) - Contemporary R&B - Label: BMG TV - Distributor: Sony Music/Arvato Services - Released: 06/09/2004 - 828766424621

User reviews (18)

Buy now for only £ 12.48

Comments about this review »

habmaster 26.07.2007 13:13

can't believe you rated this worse than late reg, this is dam near classic whereas late reg has quite a few skippables, but stil looking forward to graduation this year, but i think this year talib's 'ear drum' along with lupe's 'the cool' and saigon's 'the greatest story never told' will be the best of the year.good review!

l-m-n-o-p 28.03.2006 20:25

Good review - I'm going to have to get it after loving Late Registration

sxm171 07.09.2005 23:14

Good review, nice style. Agree with workout plan being wack but rest of album is class.

Compare prices for College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West »

1 offer for College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West   sorted by: Price 


More reviews »

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by brianroper316

Advantages: Great album, some legendary songs
Disadvantages: too many skits

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by brianroper316 brianroper316 21.08.2007 (21.08.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by funky_monkey89

Advantages: original lyrics, great beats
Disadvantages: may be too many skits

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by funky_monkey89 funky_monkey89 05.01.2005 (05.01.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by PepeDeluxe

Advantages: beats, rhymes and life, what a hip hop album should be
Disadvantages: maybe too many skits..oh, and maybe Slow Jamz :P

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by PepeDeluxe PepeDeluxe 30.06.2004 (30.06.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by lilro

Advantages: Smooth beats, catchy lyrics a classic
Disadvantages: nuffin wrong with this album make sure you buy it

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by lilro lilro 31.07.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by ben-lloyd

Advantages: Kids seem to like it
Disadvantages: repetitive beats, lyrics and rhythms

College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West - review by ben-lloyd ben-lloyd 08.07.2004 (08.07.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West



Are you the manufacturer / provider of College Dropout, The [PA] - Kanye West? Click here