To be honest, when I knew Alicia's second album was coming out I was dubious. I certainly didnt rush to the shops to buy it. After the success of Songs in A minor, I was concerned that its successor would be a weak follow-up.
Overall I was proved wrong. Having heard 'U dont know my name' played endlessly on the radio I loved the track but was worried that the album would be selling on this song alone. However, a few listens proves that although it is a strong song there are others that rival its soulful success.
Strongest tracks on this album are those where Alicia concentrates on a more soul type vibe. Whether she uses the more old-skool sound of soul revival, as in 'If i were your woman' or a more updated soul vibe as evidenced in 'Diary' these songs are strong and cohesive. I would say they show off her voice fantastically whilst sustaining a fantastic emotional intensity. 'If i aint got you' is an amazing song as well as a great showcase of her talents.
The songs that have been written by Alicia alone are definitely not as impressive. Karma, and Heartburn as well as the hip-hop inspired collboration 'streets of new york' are the weakest links in an otherwise impressive album.
Despite this, Alicia's voice stands the test of weak songs and the album is certainly a successful follow-up to her debut. In many ways I think it evidences a more cohesive sound and her maturing vocal expression.
For the classic tracks on the album, its definitely worth owning.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Whereas Alicia Keys's debut was in essence a musical overview that recorded snapshots of ... more
her life over the five years it took to complete, her follow up,The Diary Of, is the scribbled footnotes of the very busy two years since. She's certainly kept tab...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Jun 26th, 2004
very helpful by (11%):
helpful by (89%):
