Holst: The Planets (2 pianos)

Review of

Holst: The Planets (2 pianos)

Overall rating (1): Overall user rating Holst: The Planets (2 pianos)

 

All Holst: The Planets (2 pianos) reviews

 Write your own review


 


 


A trip around the solar system for £8.99

5 May 23rd, 2004

Advantages:
Unique tone poems

Disadvantages:
None

Recommendable: Yes 

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

Value for Money

more


MAFARRIMOND

About me: Kites rise highest against the wind - not with it.. (Winston Churchill)

Member since:07.12.2002

Reviews:261

Members who trust:779

Review rated by 70 Ciao members on average: very helpful

Gustav Holst: The Planets: Egdon Heath

Introduction
The Planets is one of the most popular pieces of classic music in Britain. There are countless numbers of recordings. Because of the inclusion of Egdon Heath – Holsts’ own favourite, I have chosen the recording on the Teldec label, conducted by Sir Andrew Davis and performed by the BBC Symphony Orchestra and BBC Symphony Chorus. Released in October 1994. It is my view that Sir Andrew Davies interpretation of Holst is one of the best.

The Composer
Gustavus Theodore von Holst was born in Cheltenham on 21st September 1874 (by happy coincidence this is also my birthday well the month and day but not the year.). He had a musical upbringing. His father was a piano teacher and from an early age Gustav was encouraged to practice the piano daily. He also studied the violin and trombone. As a boy, Gustav’s suffered from a number of health problems including asthma and neuritis in his right arm and was also short sighted.

Determined to follow a musical career he studied at the Royal College of Music and went on to teach this subject at St Paul's Girls' School in Hammersmith, where he composed many of his works.

Holst was in his forties when he began work on an orchestral suite, entitled 'Seven Pieces for Large Orchestra'. This was to become The Planets and was completed in 1916. Each piece portrays a mood, intended to represent the characteristics of each planet based on the book 'What is a Horoscope?' by Alan Leo.

The Planets
For orchestra & female chorus, Op. 32
No 1: Mars, The Bringer of War
Holst made the decision to perform Mars at a fast tempo to emphasise the inhuman forces utilized and mechanized strategy behind war. Mars is confident and forceful. The battle music is dominated by the repeated rhythm and develops the feeling of the relentless movement of war highlighting the doom that precedes it and the cruelty and violence that accompanies it. Holst actually composed this early in 1914 just before the horrors of the First World War were to unfold.

No 2: Venus, the Bringer of Peace
Holst placed this movement purposefully after Mars to contrast further the effects of war with the calm of peace. He is said to have taken his inspiration from the words of Alan Leo: "Venus creates orderly harmonic motion.... everywhere it produces order out of disorder, harmony out of discord." The mood of this movement is one of calmness and tranquillity with the feminine charm of Venus shining through.

No 3: Mercury, the Winged Messenger
The planet Mercury is situated closer to the sun than any of the other known and as such has the shortest year in the solar system. The effect of this short year is that from Earth Mercury seams to flit relatively quickly across the heavens, due to this feature Mercury was seen as the winged messenger of the planets. Accordingly this movement is lively and fun. Mercury can be heard flittering and flickering about. The melodic line rises and falls delightfully moving around without any regular pattern. According to Alan Leo, Mercury represents the personalities of earthly life.

No 4: Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity
This is most played and most recognised of all the movements. The mood of this piece is very much in keeping with the astrological interpretation of Jupiter as the planet of benevolence and generosity. A fanfare of woodwind opens the movement in a bustle of activity. This is followed by a relaxed and majestic sense of self-satisfaction and smugness. Jupiter appears to invite all to share in his Jollity and moves with the music swirls and gracefully dances. In the centre of the movement is a singing melody. This was later set to the words to a famous poem by Sir Cecil Spring-Rice. The first verse of which was played at the Royal Wedding of Charles and Diana and the second at Diana's funeral.

No 5: Saturn, the Bringer of Old Age
Holst based Saturn on a previous work, Dirge and Hymeneal. Alternating chords open the movement reminiscent of the sound of the church bells. A slow and solemn procession of woodwind instruments moves forward rising to a climax in a series of syncopated gasps vividly portraying a struggle for breath. The movement then relaxes into a serene and peaceful mood of acceptance.

No 6: Uranus, the Magician
Described as a nightmarish version of Dukas' Sorcerer's Apprentice. In a similar manner, Holst uses his music to depict the awe, anticipation excitement and wonderment, which are felt by an observer as a magician works himself up to a climax the completing his trick. The movement has a lively skipping rhythm and Holst utilizes dominant brass instruments and drums from the start to build up to the climax. For the climax Holst writes in a striking glissando (a rapid ascending slide across the full organ keyboard).

No 7: Neptune, the Mystic
Alone in the depth of space at the far reaches of our solar system is Neptune (Pluto having not yet been discovered by astronomers however its existence had at the time Holst composed this peace been predicted by theoretical scientists.) This movement portrays the loneliness and emptiness of space where Neptune roams. Holst direction for this movement was “dead tone, except for the clarinet”. The tone is indeed vague portraying no emotional feeling until a wordless chorus enters accompanying the orchestra. They are left on their own and then fade away to nothingness.

Egdon Heath

For orchestra, Op.47
Egdon Heath was dedicated to the memory of Thomas Hardy who Holst visited whilst in Dorset. Egdon Heath is a vast expanse of Moorland between Dorchester and Bournemouth and is utilised as the backdrop to Thomas Hardy’s Return of the Native. In fitting with Hardy's style of writing, the piece is a serious and morose portraying dark threatening clouds. The deep bass underlines the activity of the higher strings depicting a storm over a wild torrid heath. The storm relaxes and the bass is plucked to represent the resumption of normality. The strings continue in a melancholany style. A fanfare sounds, the music quietens and fades away.

The Conductor
Andrew Davis has been the Chief Conductor of the BBC Symphony Orchestra since 1989.

The Orchestra
The orchestra for this recording is extended to include quadruple woodwind, six horns, an organ and two timpanists.

The Chorus
The chorus as the title suggests (For orchestra & female chorus, Op. 32) is comprised of female voices alone.

Reasons to buy
Music based on astrology is rare. The piece is almost unique in its idea and style.
The music is dramatic and is memorable. Themes from the Planets have been used in numerous films and television scores and for advertising including Paradise Road, The Right Stuff, The Quatermass Experiment and Dulux Weather shield, to name but a few. Listen out when you get to know the pieces and you will no doubt find hundreds of other examples.

Priced at £8.99 the CD is eminently affordable and for the pleasure and entertainment it brings great value for money.
 

Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
jonnylove

jonnylove

25.01.2005 23:24

excellent review well done

Puma1000

Puma1000

24.01.2005 02:19

Holst is up there with the best of the composers. Puma1000

davideggett

davideggett

07.11.2004 01:13

Helpfull review. I remember having to 'study' Holst's 'the planets' for a music essay at school. Hated it back then but it's grown on me ever the years (having occasionally heared bits played on classic FM). Might just buy the CD now.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment


Similar offers
Holst - The Planets - Holst - The Planets - Holst: The Planets -
Holst -​ The Planets - Holst -​ The Planets - Holst: The Planets -
amazon.co.uk amazon.co.uk amazon.co.uk
£ 12.69 £ 6.79 £ 8.79
Postage & Packaging: Free!
more
Postage & Packaging: Free!
more
Postage & Packaging: Free!
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
amazon.​co.​uk amazon.​co.​uk amazon.​co.​uk
Review Ratings
This review of Holst: The Planets (2 pianos) has been rated:

"exceptional" by (9%):
  1. Puma1000
  2. Tamara99
  3. lannazus
and 3 other members

"very helpful" by (86%):
  1. SweetCaroline2
  2. jonnylove
  3. luckyarchers
and 57 other members

"helpful" by (6%):
  1. davideggett
  2. andrew51
  3. kepler3001
and a further member

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Products you might be interested in
Purcell: Complete Fantasia for Viols
1CD(s) - Label:Simax - Distributor:New Note - Run Time:1 hour 51 minutes - DDD - Released:11/1996 - 7025560112423
This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now
Buy now for only £ 12.69
Dorati: Works for Oboe and Piano; Holliger: Oboe Sonata
1CD(s) - Label:Ambroisie - Distributor:New Note - Released:08/09/2003 - 3760020170332
This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now
Buy now for only £ 12.69
The Magic Flute of James Galway
1CD(s) - Label:Gold Seal - Distributor:BMG UK - Run Time:1 hour 48 minutes - ADD - Released:06/1992 - 35626091828
This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now
Buy now for only £ 4.98
Related products on eBay