Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Quote-start

Take me Home Country ...

Quote-end

3 Jan 31st, 2003 

19 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Pleasant enough county rock

Disadvantages:
Needed a “big one”

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

How does it rate alongside the competition

Value for Money

Newfloridian

Newfloridian

About me:

*** Green Tea nears 10000! *** And another milestone for the Premium Bonds review at over 32,000. W...

Member since:13.11.2002

Reviews:328

Members who trust:82

Perhaps, surprisingly given my musical tastes, I really enjoyed the previous album release “Fly” by the Dixie Chicks. I certainly wasn’t alone as it was a phenomenal seller in the US and won several music awards to boot. The girls – Natalie Maines (Lead vocals), Martie Seidel (Fiddle, viola, vocals) and Emily Robison (Guitar, banjo, vocals) - are all accomplished musicians and pleasing on the eye too. Although they have not made much impact in the UK, I felt it would be reasonable to buy their new output “Home” unheard.

What with marriages, liaisons, babies and wrangling over contract with record labels, there has probably not been much time for singing recently. Consequently there has been a gap of almost three years between these albums and a change of record label.

The Dixie Chicks have built up a reputation of being an amalgam of country, blue grass and rock’n’roll. “Fly” traded heavily on this mixture and is perhaps the reason why it did appeal to such a wide ranging audience. There were also a couple of “stand out” tracks on it which grabbed air play attention. “Home“ is a much more thoughtful, much slower, back to country roots affair. Previously they have written most of their own songs – here they have relied more heavily on established songwriters. However they have been more committed to their own production values and delivering their own sound.

The CD comes complete with a twenty page booklet that includes the words. There is also a multitude of photographs giving hints of the environs of their “Home” (cows, yellow rose, road map, route signs) in Texas. The back page shows an illuminated cinema hoarding which reads “We are changing the way we do business” – presumably a declaration of their feelings of the battle they had with SONY over contracts.

The running order and my own assessment (marked out of five) is given below:

LONG TIME GONE (4:10) ***

These are your country cousins joining in a Texas hoe-down. This is a bouncy fast paced happy-go-lucky song accompanied by fiddle and banjo. This track was released as a single.

LANDSLIDE (3:50) ****

This is a cover of the Stevie Nicks (Fleetwood Mac) standard. Out of curiosity I have played the two back to back. Natalie sounds very similar to Stevie here – the same honeyed voice with an edge – the same inflections and breath pattern. This version is taken at the same pace. The backing here has a little more depth.

This is a good effort

TRAVELIN’ SOLDIER (5:43) *****

What is it with this song? It has trite lyrics, a tinkling non-descript melody but with her voice, it’s oh so sad. Its boy-meets-girl, boy goes to war, boy gets killed, girl weeps on her own. It’s a Vietnam song. It’s a magical combination. It brings tears to my eyes every time it’s played.

“I cried ‘Never gonna hold the hand of another guy’,’Too young for him’, they told her, Waitin’ for the love of a travelin’ solider, our love will never end”

TRUTH No.2. (4:28) ***

Natalie sings a routine medium tempo country song (banjos and fiddles to the fore again). Pleasant enough but not particularly memorable. The words don’t me much to me either “Swing me way down South, Sing me something brave from your mouth and I’ll bring you pearls of water on my hips and the love in my lips”. Maybe I’m just not country joe lyrical enough. Anyone out there care to explain?

WHITE TRASH WEDDING (2:21) ***

With discordant harmonies in the chorus, fast finger picking banjos and dizzy fiddles this is a comic patter song. There are slants of Texas falsetto here. With lyrics like: “Say I do and kiss me quick ‘Cos baby’s on it’s way” you should get the drift.

A HOME (4:56) **

A standard slow country ballad of love lost and regret.

MORE LOVE (5:07) ****

This is another country ballad – very similar in style but slightly quicker pace to the previous track. However there are some interesting patterns and counter melodies picked out in the accompaniment using Uillean pipes, penny whistle and bodhran. The Chicks have used Irish influences to very good effect in the past, demonstrating the close links between Blue grass, Gaelic and Celtic music.

I BELIEVE IN LOVE (4:14) ***


Another slow ballad. Natalie takes a very prominent vocal with a restrained guitar and viola backing.


TORTURED TANGLED HEARTS (3:40) **

This is the second patter song of the album. Lots of finger picking with fiddles running up and down the scales. Doesn’t leave much in the memory though.

LIL JACK SLADE (2:23) ***

This is an instrumental with Emily and Martie vying with each other for speed and dexterity in the harmony and rhythms. I guess this would be the “fun spot” of a concert tour or stage performance.

GODSPEED (SWEET DREAMS) (4:42) ***

Natalie takes a very slow pace to a straight forward lullaby (well there are several babies needing attention just now). There are some gentle viola refrains. Also backing vocals are credited to EmmyLou Harris – although it’s unlikely that you would notice unless you were really looking out for her.

TOP OF THE WORLD (6:01) **

The alum closes with another slow country ballad. This one was penned by Patty Griffin, another up-and-coming country singer songwriter from the 1990s who appeared with the Dixie Chicks on their “Fly” tour. Perhaps too slow and too long!


The Dixie Chicks are clearly in charge of their own destiny now – in charge of song choice, arrangements, production. This album is certainly not as commercial in sound as their previous release and does not have that immediate appeal. It will obvious delight their huge following of loyal fans – many or most will feel at “Home” back in their blue grass and country roots. However I could not get over the feeling that the next track had to be another upbeat song like “Goodbye Earl” or a rocker like “Sin Wagon”. The irony is that, while not totally absent, this brand of country has a lot less humour in it than the last.

Overall it is a pleasant album. The vocal and musical talents again shine through. I doubt that it will have a long general shelf life.

Amazon.com (American Amazon) has a web page devoted to this album. This also includes playable excepts of the first five tracks. The address is: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00006BIMO/qid=1044006613/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8_1/102-4056837-0208943?v=glance&s=music&n=507846


HOME – Dixie Chicks (2002) CD MONUMENT/EPIC 509603-2 £11.99

(There is a more recent release of this album in the US which includes bonus DVD tracks)


 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Perhaps Love - Placido Domingo With John Denver

Perhaps Love - Placido Domingo With John Denver

1 CD(s) - Country - Label: CBS - Distributor: Sony Music/Arvato Services - Released: 05/1987 - 5099707359226

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 10.56

100 Hits - Country - Various Artists

100 Hits - Country - Various Artists

5 CD(s) - Country - Label: 100 Hits - Distributor: 2 Entertain/Sony DADC - Released: 15/10/2007 - 654378700828

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 6.20

Ultimate Dolly Parton - Dolly Parton

Ultimate Dolly Parton - Dolly Parton

1 CD(s) - Nashville Sound - Label: RCA - Distributor: Sony Music/Arvato Services - Released: 21/07/2003 - 828765420129

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 3.73

Working Class Millionaire (Translatlantic Anthology) - Richard Digance

Working Class Millionaire (Translatlantic Anthology) - Richard Digance

2 CD(s) - Folk - Label: Castle Music - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 29/05/2006 - 5050749413284

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 4.99

Voices At The Door (Midwinter Songs And Carols) - Various Artists

Voices At The Door (Midwinter Songs And Carols) - Various Artists

1 CD(s) - Folk - Label: No Masters Cooperative - Distributor: Proper - Released: 27/11/2006 - 5020393902526

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 10.48

Best Of LeAnn Rimes, The - LeAnn Rimes

Best Of LeAnn Rimes, The - LeAnn Rimes

1 CD(s) - Contemporary Country - Label: Curb/London - Distributor: Cinram Logistics - Released: 02/02/2004 - 5050467148123

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 4.24

Comments about this review »

quizzeyq 01.02.2003 00:15

Great op, i dont think i have heard them as yet. x

Bigbaz 31.01.2003 23:11

Stevie Nicks said that had she been younger she would have been a Dikie Chick, what finer praise can you get..Baz

Sarccyslayer 31.01.2003 22:52

Not my kind of music but a good op!

Compare prices for Home - Dixie Chicks »

1 offer for Home - Dixie Chicks   sorted by: Price 


More reviews »

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by Bigbaz

Advantages: Fresh Addictive Compulsive Listening
Disadvantages: To Short

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by Bigbaz Bigbaz 27.04.2003 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Home - Dixie Chicks

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by Lolly1

Advantages: fantastic lyrics
Disadvantages: most of the good songs are at the beginning of the album

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by Lolly1 Lolly1 06.09.2003 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Home - Dixie Chicks

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by guitarsteveb

Advantages: Great band that gets you singin'
Disadvantages: none

Home - Dixie Chicks - review by guitarsteveb guitarsteveb 14.09.2003 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of Home - Dixie Chicks



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Home - Dixie Chicks? Click here