Similar offers
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Postage & Packaging: £1.21
Quote-start

An alchemical experience in stereo

Quote-end

4 May 6th, 2005 

17 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Outstanding performance  of the entire work

Disadvantages:
Live recording  -  complete with audience coughs !

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

Value for Money

Tezmordo

Tezmordo

About me:

Unreformed aging Goth, hailing from the small-minded ex-mining communities of Central Scotland. Has...

Member since:06.05.2005

Reviews:4

Members who trust:1

I was first introduced to Nono's works during a BBC Radio 3 Broadcast from the Huddersfield Contemporary Music Festival several years ago, and I feel in love with his late works immediately.

Prometeo is an opera that occurs entirely without visual dramatic action. In this particular recording, the Ensemble Modern teams up with the Freiburg Soloists Choir, with Ingo Metzmacher taking the role of conductor.

The first thing to note is that the packaging itself precludes the consumer from being able to tell exactly what is contained in the set. The double-cd box and libretto are contained in a cardboard slip-case that only declares "Luigi Nono - Prometeo - Metzmacher", and the requisite stock numbers/bar-codes etc. from Sony/BMG.

Once past this minor hurdle, the package proves to be a fairly standard multi-lingual libretto, containing a short description of the work, biography of Nono, and full text of the work (with translations).

It is the recording itself that truly takes the breath away. Nono's sound-world by this period consists of subtle sustained intervals drifting languorously, with interjections of dissonance, sudden outbursts, and unusual playing techniques that create unfamiliar textures.

In particular, the Choir do a fantastic job of holding the sustained intervals (predominantly consonances of fourths, fifths or octaves), over which the narrators provide the dramatic text. Beneath these layers, the soloists of the Ensemble Modern provide a desolate landscape of over-blown winds, con battuta and sul ponticello strings, key-clicks, and other thoroughly "modern" orchestal techniques. Nono uses this to form an orchestral conversation between the lofty intentions of the eternal Gods (as symbolised by the choral layers interlocking structures and temporal expansion), and the action on the mundane world of mankind (through the striving of the instruments to achieve the perfection of the godhead).

The entire ensemble is crystal clear on this recording, as indeed it requires to be if it is attempting to translate the delicate sounds of Nono's scoring to the hi-fi realm. The room ambience microphones are also mixed perfectly on this recording - there are no huge washes of reverb, and no sterility of instrument separation either.

So, what's the catch?

It's a live recording, of a live performance, with very live audience members involved. Despite the fact the many of the audience members must have been aware that they would have to sit very quietly for around 2 hours in order to appreciate this work, some of them choose to bring along the coughs and colds that they have been nursing. Of course you could argue that this adds to the listening experience, as it simulates a true live concert, but you can't glare at the back of the cougher's head on this one!

It is hard to maintain concentration for the 2 hours, but it is worth it as you hear the gradual coalescing of the disparate elements, and their eventual dissolution also; an alchemical journey in stereo!

For the best experience, listen late at night with headphones in a darkened room. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Karajan - Complete EMI Recordings Vol 2: Opera & Choral

Karajan - Complete EMI Recordings Vol 2: Opera & Choral

72CD(s) - Label:Karajan Anniversary Collection - Distributor:EMI - Released:04/02/2008 - 5099951197322

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 80.82

Debussy: Clair de lune

Debussy: Clair de lune

1CD(s) - Label:Naxos - Distributor:Select - Run Time:1 hour 18 minutes - Released:29/03/2004 - 747313580026

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 3.98

Jacqueline Du Pré - Complete EMI Recordings

Jacqueline Du Pré - Complete EMI Recordings

17CD(s) - Label:EMI Classics - Distributor:EMI - DDD - Released:22/10/2007 - 5099950416721

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 17.98

Goodall: Eternal Light - A Requiem

Goodall: Eternal Light - A Requiem

1CD(s) - Label:EMI Classics - Distributor:EMI - DDD - Released:01/09/2008 - 5099921504723

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 3.50

100 Best Carols

100 Best Carols

6CD(s) - Label:EMI Classics - Distributor:EMI - Released:05/11/2007 - 5099950024520

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 6.98

Bach: Cello Suites

Bach: Cello Suites

2CD(s) - Label:Theta - Distributor:BMG UK - 5099708975425

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 6.65

Comments about this review »

Silverback 06.05.2005 23:53

Hope you have fun on Ciao. Good to see such a challenging and unusual subject for a first review - and a very good one at that. Paul

luseantom 06.05.2005 21:04

A cracking first review...welcome to ciao..hope you enjoy your stay here...lynz xx

ray52 06.05.2005 20:37

Hi and a warm welcome to ciao. Some super info there in your first, well-written review. I hope you enjoy the ciao experience, as I do. Ray

Related offers for Nono: Prometeo »

Amazon UK 723 Ratings

Amazon UK

Find "Nono: Prometeo" New and Used on Amazon. Free UK Delivery on orders over £25.

 Visit Shop  >
Amazon UK




Are you the manufacturer / provider of Nono: Prometeo? Click here