Trent Reznor is not a happy man. From naming his band after the length of the nails, which crucified Christ, and spouting platitudes such “Hey God, I think you owe me a great big apology” this much is obvious. The man, however, is undoubtedly talented, and along with the likes of Ministry, virtually invented the whole sub genre we now term industrial.
So it stands to reason, that this album ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ must have been incredibly influential. Well, yes and no. This is one of the earliest blends of electronica with guitar certainly, but the driving, pounding wall of sound that characterised NIN’s later work is completely absent here. It is from the ‘Broken’ Ep that the likes of Marilyn Manson, Orgy and so on were spawned. As a reference point, ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ owes an awful lot more to Depeche Mode then it does to Metallica.
This means lots of spooky sounding synth noises with some slightly tinny drum machines and few if any over powering buzzsaw guitar riffs. The album came out in 1989 and (whisper this) definitely sounds like it. The fingertips of 80s production lurk in every corner of the album. It’s a sad but true fact the records made in the 80s seem to have dated far worse then those made in almost any other era. Perhaps now we are used to our babbling Moogs and bleeps that seamlessly fly in and out of the mix, that the kitchen sink approach jars slightly. However, in the case of ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ when the whole album is constructed from this approach, this creates a slightly kitsch appeal, although compared to the ambient soundscapes of ‘The Fragile’ the record does seem woefully primitive
The opening track, ‘Head Like a Hole’ (or alternatively the NIN song they play at clubs which isn’t ‘Closer’), is
rightly regarded by many as a cast iron classic. Opening with a ticker tape of electric drums and a squeal of distorted guitar the track settles into a sparsely arranged verse before an army of guitars descend on the chorus as Reznor’s vocal changes from sneer to bellow. Addictive and heady with a hook the size of Mount Everest it remains one of my favourite songs of all time and is a flawless start. It even manages to get away with a brief drum solo.
‘Terrible Lie’ is equally wonderful. With a rhythm section which sound rather like an army of spoons battering a skull and an excellent blast of fuzzed up guitar which drifts in and out of the mix, the song showcases Reznor at his most angry and frustrated. The slightly bleepy synths which swirl in the chorus give the track a slightly nervous edge, whilst the surreal coda gives some clue to what computers would sound like if they could make music unaided. The final whispered cry of “I need someone to hold onto,” however, demonstrates Reznor’s human fragility within the alarming metal machine.
Probably the other stand out track is ‘Something I can never have’. In complete contrast to the album as whole this is a sparse piano based piece of music, which is tender, fragile and heartfelt. It sounds somewhat like a broadcast from another planet, the occasional blast of interference unsettling the listener. Reznor quietly sings the resigned lyric, the musical equivalent of slitting your wrists and watching the blood slowly drip. His voice threatens to rise to a crescendo on a number of occasions, almost as if the pain becomes too much to bear, but then slips away, reduced to the repeated cry “I just want something, I can never have.” It’s a creepy song but one that nevertheless has a horrific beauty to it.
‘Sanctified’ is also sparse and haunted, another musical attempt to exorcise demons. A church organ lurks around the mix, whilst the song itself is constructed around a circular bass line, with Reznor’s vocal at first relaxed but gradually cracking with emotion. A guitar finally enters in the chorus, but only in short spells, backed with a crashing drum as the bile seems to rise in Reznor’s throat. The atmospheric middle eight, which features Gregorian style chanting along with distorted radio noise is claustrophobic and disturbing, not the ideal song to try and get to sleep after.
‘Sin’ which was later remixed for single release is in contrast energetic and angry, a diatribe of sheer vitriol directed at a former lover. The track is dominated by a bubbling melodic bass which sounds like it belongs on a New Order track circa 1986, operating in contrast to the frantic drums and the rippling menace of the guitar, which finally explodes during the instrumental section. It is from ‘Sin’ that the sound that has come to define NIN seems to have developed, although the teeth of the anger and bile is slightly blunted by the cheap sounding synths which float around.
Which I suppose is a criticism of the album as a whole. As I listen to it again, in places it does make even myself, a big NIN fan cringe. ‘Down in it’ really does sound like a reject from the early years of the decade, featuring a slightly surreal spoken verse and at one point a refrain of “Rain, rain go away.” Even the excellent chorus with a delightful guitar flick and a powerful middle section can’t save the track from sounding a little too tacky.
Meanwhile a couple of tracks are just weak in their own right. ‘The Only Time’, again based around a prominent bass line sounds lazy and dashed off. The lyrics are perhaps the weakest on the album, and whilst the motown-esque backing vocals which appear occasionally are interesting, they can’t save the track from being frankly tedious. Final track ‘Ringfinger’ is another offender, blatantly stealing some of the melody and bass line from the Eurythmics hit ‘Sweet Dreams’. The track meanders along, failing to engage the listener or discover anything approximating a memorable tune.
Lyrically Reznor presents an intriguing puzzle. At a first listen the lyrics seem to be standard teenage-esque angst complete with overwrought self pity and self hatred. Certainly plenty here to appeal to the black trench coat Mafia. Look a little deeper and recurring themes of eyes both being covered and injured appear. Also noticeable is the preoccupation with religious imagery. Whilst NIN’s later work has occasionally touched on this, most noticeably in the somewhat blasphemous ‘Heresy’ (“He dreamed a God up / And called it Christianity / Your God is dead / And no-one cares.”). On ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ the religious references are more frequent but yet less explicit. Whilst ‘Head Like a Hole’ is undoubtedly dedicated to Mamon (“God, money I’ll do anything for you”), songs such as ‘Sanctified’ add religious metaphor to a destructive relationship, “Heaven’s just a rumour she’ll dispel / As she walks me through the niceset parts of hell.” ‘Ringfinger’ and ‘The Only Time’ meanwhile suggest a Christ complex, “I’ll be dying for your sins and aiding the cause” is a memorable example. Whether Reznor uses these images to deliberately shock as his protégée Marilyn Manson would later take to extremes or to highlight a genuine struggle with faith is naturally debatable, although the self laceration demonstrated in ‘Sin’ perhaps suggests the latter.
So what is there to say in conclusion? ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ is undoubtedly a classic and will remain a record I am very fond of. Whilst the production and instrumentation has dated incredibly since 1989, in general the songs still stand up 12 years later. A strong testament to the ability of Reznor. Those who came in with ‘The Downward Spiral’ or ‘The Fragile’ may be puzzled by this album, the style contrasts so much with NIN’s later work in general. However, those who have been scared by the noise usually created by industrial will find an easy entrance here, where the melody and lyrics are clearly audible over the mayhem. I can still recommend ‘Pretty Hate Machine’ as an excellent album, albeit one which bears all the hall marks of 80s musical excess.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Again a fantastic op, and you are a fellow NIN fan! What do you think of The Fragile? I imagine you could write a really great op on it! I'm adding you to my CoT so I can come back and visit. Vicky
alexandrapontecaille 05.07.2001 22:25
Thx for this great op, very well written and it comes from the heart. It has been about 5 years I haven't listen to this group.
well done.
Alex
mjbarkley 06.06.2001 15:30
Good op thamks. I've never heard of nine inch nails apart from the ones sold at the hardware store.
Considered the breakthrough album that delivered a more palatable version of industrial ... more
music to the commercial audience,Pretty Hate Machineleft its dingy mark on pop culture. The abrasive "sonarchy" of the album was first churned by despondent club-go...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Considered the breakthrough album that delivered a more palatable version of industrial ... more
music to the commercial audience, Pretty Hate Machine left its dingy mark on pop culture. The abrasive "sonarchy" of the album was first churned by despondent club-...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Considered the breakthrough album that delivered a more palatable version of industrial ... more
music to the commercial audience,Pretty Hate Machineleft its dingy mark on pop culture. The abrasive "sonarchy" of the album was first churned by despondent club-go...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Considered the breakthrough album that delivered a more palatable version of industrial ... more
music to the commercial audience, Pretty Hate Machine left its dingy mark on pop culture. The abrasive "sonarchy" of the album was first churned by despondent club-...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...