S&M - Metallica/Michael Kamen/San Francisco Symphony Orchestra

Review of

S&M - Metallica/Michael Kamen/San Francisco Symphony Orchestra

Overall rating (7): Overall user rating S&M - Metallica/Michael Kamen/San Francisco Symphony Orchestra

1 offers from £8.95 to £8.95  

All S&M - Metallica/Michael Kamen/San Francisco Symphony Orchestra reviews

 Write your own review


 


 


A mash of 2 genres

4 Mar 12th, 2006

Advantages:
The best of metallica, redone

Disadvantages:
Too melodic for some peoples tastes, some tracks just don't feel right

Recommendable: Yes 

Detailed rating:

Originality

Lyrics

Quality and consistency of tracks

How does it compare to the artist's other releases

Value for Money

more


metallicstone

About me: Enjoy my reviews. Personally im a bit of a PC fanatic and i spend a fair bit on my pc and enjoy clas...

Member since:16.02.2006

Reviews:12

Members who trust:2

Review rated by 13 Ciao members on average: helpful

Metallica's finest songs, all together on one double CD album, what could be better? Well for some fans this album was a bit of a letdown. The songs are still their in essence, but things have changed. The added orchestral support does make this entire album very melodic, and to be honest this really doesn't suit some Metallica songs, such as Fuel and Battery, in fact it completely slaughters them. It doesn't sound like metallica being true to who they are. Aside from this if you are an avid fan you will enjoy this album anyway. It does have to be said however, that since it is live, Hetfield's voice does sound a bit old and used, which doesn't help the feeling that Metallica is going down in a slow painful spiral.

The two completely new tracks are good, but it has to be pointed out that they were wqritten with the orchestra in mind, and as a concequence fit together well but completely miss the Metallica - thrash/metal image.

The guitar solos are still there and when the guitar solos kick in it does seem that Metallica aren't dead yet. Probably my favourite track on the album is Until it sleeps, although Sad but true comes close, with it's powerful guitar and meaingful lyrics.

In summary this album is a good choice for hardcore fans, but isn't a very good introduction to the real Metalica. Some of the older fans who remeber Kill 'Em All may feel a little cheated by this album as it is unlike every other album. It does have to be said though, that the idea is daring and mostly well pulled off.

 

Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
supercityfan

supercityfan

13.03.2006 13:37

I can't begin to imagine how Metallica and an orchestra together would sound. Certainly an interesting concept !!

abbichicken

abbichicken

12.03.2006 14:03

I thought this was an amazing, amazing album myself but agree it wasn't to all fans' tastes! A bit more track info and detail on this review would be good, cause there's loads you might not expect to find there...otherwise great!

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment
Compare Prices sorted by Price
S&M (2CD) - CD

S&M (2CD) - CD

The Ecstasy Of Gold The Call Of The Ktulu Master Of Puppets Of Wolf And Man The ...

more

£ 8.95 play.com (music) 337 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: £0.​0...

Availability: 3-​5 working days

     Visit Shop  

play.com (music)



Compare prices
S&M (2CD) - CD
S&M (2CD) - CD
play.com (music)
£ 8.95
Postage & Packaging: £0.​0...
more
 Visit Shop
play.com (music)
Review Ratings
This review of S&M - Metallica/Michael Kamen/San Francisco Symphony Orchestra has been rated:

"helpful" by (100%):
  1. Soho_Black
  2. supercityfan
  3. welshfruitbat
and 10 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Products you might be interested in
And Justice For All - Metallica And Justice For All - Metallica
1 CD(s) - Speed / Thrash Metal - Label: Vertigo - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 10/1988 - 42283606227
19 reviews
Buy now for only £ 6.25
S&M - Metallica S&M - Metallica
1 CD(s) - Heavy Metal - Label: Universal IMS - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 03/03/2003 - 731454679718
27 reviews
Buy now for only £ 9.99
Lest We Forget (The Best Of Marilyn Manson) [PA] - Marilyn Manson Lest We Forget (The Best Of Marilyn Manson) [PA] - Marilyn Manson
1 CD(s) - Heavy Metal - Label: Interscope - Distributor: Universal Music - Released: 27/09/2004 - 602498638835
5 reviews
Buy now for only £ 5.99
Related products on eBay