Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The)
Product Information

Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The) > Reviews > Cutting Through The Electronic Barriers

2 CD(s) - Classic Electronic - Label: Brille - Distributor: PIAS UK/Sony DADC - Released: 02/07/2007 - 94638865124

3 offers from £7.42 to £11.50

Overall user rating Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The) 1 review | Write a review





Please wait ....
Rate this product:  
 
All Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The) reviews
Cutting Through The Electronic Barriers
A review by Tubthumper17 on Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The)
January 31st, 2008


Author's product rating:   Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The) - rated by Tubthumper17

Originality Definitely a cut above the rest 
Lyrics Thought-provoking 
Quality and consistency of tracks Flawless 
How does it rate alongside the competition Outstanding 
Value for Money Excellent 

Advantages: Good for dancing or chilling out, great tracks, 2 CDs and 1 DVD for around £12
Disadvantages: None

Recommend to potential buyers: yes 

Full review
I got into The Knife after hearing Like A Pen when a friend took the "Silent Shout" album round for background music during a game of poker. After the first listen of this album, the poker became part of the background as we listened to this. I have never been into the electronic genre, but I am now starting to make in roads to it, as this album has really opened my eyes as to what is out there. It surprises me to know that they are not that well known at all. These guys deserve some recognition.


Silent Shout
This album takes you in on the first listen, and the title track starts with a thumping bass, which you'd maybe expect to find in a dance track, but 10 seconds in, it opens up with the keyboard. It's a song you could dance to, as well as just chill out to. 9/10

Neverland
This is also another good mixture of keyboards, drums and bass. Not my favourite song on the album, but I love the breakdown at 1:54 which lasts until 2:58. 7/10

The Captain
This song does not really kick in until about 2:44 as those first two and a half minutes are filled with weird, distorted keyboards. It's a bit slow and not too catchy, so not a great track in my opinion. 5/10

We Share Our Mother's Health
A stand out track on the album. It's upbeat, has the electronic drum and bass, synthesiser and some strange lyrics. A brilliant song to dance to. If you want to get into The Knife, you need to listen to this song. 9/10

Na Na Na
This is a really spaced out track, with it's echoey, distorted lyrics and the backing track reminds me in someone playing steel drums on a beach somewhere far away, which can only be a god thing! 8/10

Marble House
Begins with the sound effect of what could easily be described as marbles hitting one another, and the keyboard then kicks in a crescendo style. Has a good solid bass beat in the background, and the keyboards and lyrics compliment each other well. 7/10

Like A Pen
As this is the song that got me into The Knife, this is obviously a favourite of mine. It's like they've made a song with the sound effect of a dripping tap and it's brilliant! You could easily dance to this or chill out to it. The drums and keyboard also work well together in this track. 10/10

From Off to On
A very subdued and quiet track, perfect for sitting down and letting your mind wander as you relax. 8/10

Forest Families
This track starts off with another dance-esqe beginning with the rhythm of the synthesiser. Although from the previous tracks, you know it isn't going to be a commercial put your hands up and rave like a loony song. The style of the lyrics contradict the backing synthesier as they are quite subdued and echoey meaning this is also another chill out track. 8/10

One Hit
Another favourite of mine. The drums and the style of the vocals are brilliant, and you can feel yourself itching just to sing the chorus, because it's just so random. 9/10

Still Light
Slow track, another which sounds slightly spaced out and the vocals help to convey this style. You expect the final song on a CD to be a bit more upbeat, so that was slightly disappointing, but nevertheless a good track. 7/10


The next CD is a compilation of live recordings from The Knife and these let you at least feel some part of what it is like at a gig. It features a few of the songs already mentioned, plus a few others from their other albums. 8/10

I actually do not own the DVD as part of this set, which is a pity, but from what I have heard it is a good watch!

To conclude, if you've never really expereinced the electronic scene much like myself, but would like to explore and expand your music taste, this album is a must for you. I'm a relative newbie at the whole genre, but this album has really made me realise the sort of things I've been missing. On the other hand, if you're into the electronic genre, and you've never heard of The Knife, I suggest you get this album too just to broaden your horizons, as I believe it is slightly unique to other artists. 
Write your own review




More details
How does it compare to the artist's other releases Outstanding 
Cover / Inlay Design and Content Satisfactory 

Evaluate this review
How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?
Rating guidelines

   

Comments on this review
More options
All Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The) reviews

Compare prices for Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The)

3 out of 3 offers for Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The)   sorted by Price  
Silent Shout: +DVD
Release Date: 2007-07-02, Audio CD, Brille
£ 7.42 Amazon Marketplace

Postage & PackagingCheck Site.
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 2 working days...
Amazon Marketplace
Silent Shout: +DVD - Knife
Release Date: 2007-07-02, Audio CD, Brille
£ 10.99 Amazon.co.uk

Postage & Packaging£1.46
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
Amazon.co.uk


Are you the manufacturer / provider of Silent Shout (+DVD) - Knife (The)? Click here