I'd like to begin this review by discussing the term RnB. Depending on how old you are, or perhaps how stuck in your ways you are if you're like me lol, you'll have different interpretations of what the genre RnB entails. Now to me, RnB means classic RnB: I'd be thinking of bands like The Stones, Cream and Fleetwood Mac, whereas others would be thinking of people such as Aaliyah, Destiny's Child and Brandy. There is nothing wrong with either understanding of the term, but I tend to call the latter artists "Modern" RnB acts, as you could hardly imagine them being capable of pulling out a guitar or drum kit could you now? This modernisation of musical terms has extended to other areas such as soul and swing and now we're in such a position where if you go into a music shop such as MVC who tend to daftly separate pop and rock and RnB and hip hop, you don't know where to look for what you want. I don't mind them separating the genres, but it's all down to your own understanding as to whether for instance Papa Roach are rock, or whether although they are rock, are they poppy enough to be put in pop? It's all getting out of hand if you ask me :).
Anyone who knows me well will know that for the most part, I just can't be doing with modern RnB music. The problem being that most of the artists seem to have such an attitude problem and tend to have an arrogance that even Jay Kay would be ashamed of, but that's just my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I did like it in the mid 90s, when groups like En Vogue, SWV and the sublime Mary J Blyge ruled the roost, but in those days, RnB was far more melodic and tonal. I do sound like I am getting old if you read this I agree, but it's the same with a lot of musical genres these days, house music, rock and RnB are all moving away from producing a great melody with thought provoking lyrics, they tend to place more emphasis on the overall feel of the music and the music video.
Just when I thought all was lost and I was going to give up on last year's music, I met my mate from Barnsley last weekend. We ended up getting totally pissed and I nursed a hangover for most of the weekend after that, but a hangover wasn't the only thing I came home with. We'd been talking about music a lot as we inevitably do and I was saying how much I liked Alicia Keys single releases. A few minutes later he was delving into his bag and producing an MD with Songs In A Minor on it - I was chuffed and on the Saturday night when everyone else had gone out, I settled down in front of the stereo hoping that the diva would soothe my aching head and limbs with her vocal charms.
… and how delighted
I was with the album. I'm sure that I'll only be backing up what everyone else has said when I say that Keys is a great new artist; in fact I'd go further and point out that she is a phenomenal talent and a young star in the making who has the musical world at her feet. At the age of only 20, Keys has produced what I see as one of the finest albums this millennium and quite rightly so, she and it were nominated for awards in this year's Grammy ceremonies. Alicia had been writing songs since her early teens and also had over 10 years of classical piano training at her disposal. On top of this, she had experience in a gospel choir and music college pedigree to draw upon. Put all this into perspective and you'd think that this album was going to be hot - and indeed it was …
The album begins very serenely with a rendition of Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata - a beautiful classical piece that is backed up with some soft choir work until launching into the RnB beats. You'd think that this would have murdered the piece and judging by the key and the tempo, I was expecting it to launch straight into Fallin', but surprisingly enough, it didn't.
The following track Girlfriend had me wondering in dismay as to what I'd let myself in for. It was the kind of RnB that I wasn't fond of - too much "uh, yeah"ing and with a repetitive melody. The piano abilities aren't overly well displayed here and I don't think this track is exactly inspirational.
Luckily, the remainder of the album offers much in the realms of musical creativity and vocal ability. A swinging piano introduction with an American dial tone poses the beginning of the 3rd track until the lilting vibes of the song begin. Much more laid back and with a great display of vocal range, this moody and searching number with a gospel undertone (twangs of organ especially backing this up) is a fine cover of Prince's Why Don't You Call Me No More.
Next comes Fallin, probably the song that shot Keys to fame. This has a great yet simplistic piano riff that is the backbone of the song with the same and popular 6/8 timing so well used by people such as Stevie Wonder and Sade. This haunting and uncertain melody is catchy and well produced - with Alicia pondering how her moods are always changing and hence her feelings for her bloke. Keys voice blends in a lot with the backing singers on this track - perhaps a little too much as she has already displayed that she has an awesome voice and it's a shame to see it hidden amongst the others. This is mainly because of her youth, it seems that her voice is far more articulate than older artists such as Mariah Carey or Whitney Houston and therefore she can flaunt her young unfagged, unboozed voice to her heart's content. Cracking drum work and sharp production clearly marked this one as a single.
The next 3 or 4 tracks continue in the laid back tuneful way that the previous two tracks have set. Troubles is a slow paced and more Mary J influenced track with cracking syncopated drumming and keys' trademark piano stamping her authority on this mildly melancholic track. Rock Wit You on the other hand is a much more pacey affair featuring the soul legend Isaac Hayes on Rhodes piano. This, along with a few other tracks from the album in my opinion draw strong influences from the work of Sade and Roberta Flack as there are firm elements of jazz incorporated - in fact Rock Wwit you is a firm and funky number with some retro style strings and wah wah guitar to cement the bouncy and tight drumming. This is what Sade's comeback effort Lover's Rock should have sounded like!
We come now then to the other popular single from the album, A Woman's Worth. With a film score type orchestral introduction with essence of oboe, we approach a more acid jazz influenced slow paced number. There's a strong base line going on as well as some lovely electric piano, and although some of the lyrics approaching the chorus might have some people's tongue in a twist: "You will lose if you choose to refuse to put her first / she will and she can find a man who knows her worth", this is a superbly jaunty song with attitude - all about learning to appreciate your partner and knowing when you've got a good thing. I saw a superb live rendition of this on SMTV recently with the soully sounds of the Memphis guitar more prominent in the mix but this studio version is again crisp and well produced. This is probably because as well as having well known RnB act Brian McKnight on her production team, Keys has had her own input on producing every single track meaning that it'd hopefully sound exactly as she wanted it to.
We're now coming onto my favourite area of the album - 5 or 6 superbly solid tracks in a row. Before that however, comes Jane Doo; again it's one of the more cut and thrust traditional approaches to RnB with the strident lyrics about men and love but as always Keys is tickling the classical ivories in the background - whether she's trying to make a point on culture or class remains to be seen and although this track isn't lyrically excellent it's good enough and has a strong melody and brisk feel.
So now to my favourite part of the album - and why? Well there are some fantastic songs here with melodic excellence and some fully fledged piano that uses every ounce of the keyboards length and weighted notes - something that I never fail to appreciate. The first of the purple patch, Goodbye, is without a doubt my favourite track from the album. It has a great roving piano intro that gives way to a mellow and nostalgic modern soul ballad. Keys voice is at it's richest here and the song is all about losing the person she loves: "Well how do I let go / when I've loved him for so long / and I've given him all I could". Some of the piano work reminds me tentatively of Almaz by Randy Crawford and Keys definitely has the potential to become as great a soul voice as the woman herself.
The album also yields another gem, The Life, that sits back to back with the highlight of the LP Goodbye. This in my opinion has very strong routes in Latin jazz with all the appropriate Latin percussion and sweltering funky baselines. Everything about this song suggests heat and intimacy - it does have an urban feel, especially with the lyrics talking about surviving on the streets and getting by but this is a stylish 4 minutes of pure tunage. Sergio Mendez would have been proud of this one I tell you - top marks to Alicia and her accompanying guitarist for this track.
I think I'd better b a bit more brief - although this LP is 16 tracks long. Keys gives her vocal chords a bit of a rest for a while as guest vocalist Jimmy Cozier expresses himself alongside a backing that doesn't sound too dissimilar from Teardrop and a string section with some Morcheeba like violin work. There is again a strong South American feel to this song and although Keys wrote virtually every track on the album herself this stands out in style a little so maybe she was given a hand with it.
The stunning bit of virtuoso piano in the brief interlude (with the reverb and melody doing just enough to give it the solitary feel that shines through) gives way to Butterflies. This track carries on exactly where the interlude left off - you don't notice the join and the last 2 or 3 songs have indicated the sheer adaptability of Keys; as in some tracks she can sound as raunchy and ready as Whitney Houston or TLC's Lisa Left Eye whereas in others she can sound as sweet and balanced as Shola Ama. These 2 linkup tracks have no accompaniment so they do give your speakers a rest and show you Alicia's strong chilled out and classical sides.
The album ties itself up with the duet of songs Why Do I Feel So Sad and Caged Bird. The first being a bitter sweet urban feeling groove (she's definitely been listening to too much Anita Baker and Sade and just modernised it lol) and the second being a blissfully calm almost a capella piece where you get the impression Keys is almost singing to herself. A conclusive effort to finish the album - apart from the 2 remixes that sit on the end (if you’ve got the special edition like me).
So my verdict? Well I am well and truly sold as far as Alicia Keys goes. Even if you're not a great modern RnB fan as I am not, there is still so much on this album that will appeal to you and if you are a fanatic of the genre it should also please your ears. I don't buy too many modern albums until I have heard a good deal of material from them as they are more often than not filled with mediocre B sides and album fillers. Although I was a little late in purchasing this album (it came out in July of last year), Alicia Keys is the best up and coming talent I've encountered since Dido and I hope to see her go on to achieve big things.
Although it is a little odd in the way it contrasts RnB and classical remedies here and there it comes highly recommended from me and just about scrapes the 5 star margin.
Ta very much for reading :)
Craig - April 2002
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines