How does it compare to the artist's other releases
Not applicable
Value for Money
Good
Advantages:
Songs never grow old, surprisingly good versions by interesting artists
Disadvantages:
You may not like all the artists on the album, but that shouldn't stop you
Recommend to potential buyers:
yes
Full review
Little can be added to the praise that has always been heaped on Carole King's album "Tapestry". But a group of artists have found a better way than words to show their admiration and love for this practically perfect collection of songs. With a plethora of artists from Celine Dion to Manhattan Transfer to Rod Stewart, this Tribute will appeal to practically everyone. Granted, not all the artists' will suit the taste of true lovers of the original clear clean voice that we know as Carole King, but there is a lot to recommend this album.
My personal favorite track on this album is Manhattan Transfer's version of "Smackwater Jack". This ballad like song, with its slightly country overtones, seems to fit the voices of this group like a glove. They've done nothing particularly special with the song, but still, it seems like they have revitalized it.
You might not blame me if my least favorite track was Celine Dion's version of "(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman", but I was pleasantly surprised at her interpretation, and have decided, for this one time, to ignore my previous feelings about Dion's ability and choice of songs.
Some people would find Rod Stewart's version of "So Far Away" difficult to swallow. I know that on my first listening, I found it hard to listen to his scratchy voice on this beloved song. But, rather than give up on the interpretation, I gave it several more chances, and I must admit it is starting to grow on me.
The Bee Gees sing "Will You Love Me Tomorrow?" on this album, and - as expected - they sound like they always have sounded. If you like them, you'll like their version. If not, you'll hate it.
I've got to say that "You've Got A Friend" sung by Bebe & Cece Winans featuring Aretha Franklin, is a real treat - and I never heard of Bebe or Cece before! Learn something new...
Although I wouldn't purchase this tribute album in lieu of the original Carole King, any lover of her songs and the original album just shouldn't be without it. Four stars but certainly recommended.
