The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Advantages:
Alanis back doing what she does best, writing infectious but powerful songs, Demonstrates a more mature approach both musically and lyrically, 'At That Particular Time', 'Precious Illusions'
Disadvantages:
'You Owe me Nothing' edges a bit too close to filler for comfort, It's still recognisably Alanis, so if you hated 'Jagged Little Pill' you'd best steer clear
Recommendable
Yes:
Detailed rating:
Originality
Lyrics
Quality and consistency of tracks
How does it compare to the artist's other releases
Value for Money
How does it rate alongside the competitionOutstanding
It can't be easy selling 28 million copies of what is effectively your debut album, just ask Alanis Morissette who in 1995 found herself catapulted into the mainstream collective consciousness with 'Jagged Little Pill'. Neatly filling the role of Courtney Love's more palatable younger sister, Morisette mixed the fury and noise of grunge with neat pop melodies, a pretty face and the classic vulnerability of the best singer songwriters. Along with the likes of Sheryl Crow and Tori Amos she pushed the female singer songwriter genre right back to centre stage and spawned an army of imitators, most of whom faded back to obscurity soon after (where are you now Meredeth Brooks eh?). By rights such sudden success shouldn't have gone to her head, Morissette after all had had in effect a trial run as a pop starlet in her native Canada between the ages of 16 to 18.
However a series of exhausting world tours and perhaps one too many sessions in intensive therapy wreaked their damage. By 1997 the average interview with Morissette seemed to consist of little more then a deluge of psychobabble and worst fears were confirmed by her 1998 sophomore effort 'Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie'. The title really says it all (although not quite in the same league of pretension as the title of the second Fiona Apple album admittedly), a dense, practically impenetrable mess of 17 tracks which contained a virtual ocean of seething lyrics but little more then a small pond of melody (the single 'Thank U' being a notable exception). It alienated the vast majority of her audience and forced Morissette into a virtually hermit like retreat from which she has only just emerged (well she was in a Gap advert last year but methinks this doesn't count).
So four years on and in the face of declining audiences for the genre she helped revitalise, Morissette has a lot of ground to make up with 'Under Rug Swept'. Initial signs don't look too promising, Morissette has split with producer/co-writer Glen Ballard who presided over 'Jagged...' and much of 'Supposed...' and has opted for self production, all too often the last refuge of the over inflated artistic ego. So it is something of a pleasant surprise to announce that 'Under Rug Swept' is Morissette's finest album to date by quite some margin, largely returning to the territory she so thrilling inhabited on 'Jagged Little Pill' but also suggesting artistic progression. Gone are the unwieldy dictatorial swathes of lyrics that characterised 'Supposed...' and in their place are driving melodies, tangible and effective hooks and sharp witty couplets that cut to the point rather then giving us a complete emotional history. Unashamed pop rock tracks such as flyer single 'Hands Clean' and 'Surrendering' see Alanis setting out her stall: strong choruses, lashings
of guitar and plenty of bite in the vocals.
'Under Rug Swept' however, for the first time also showcases a growing maturity. Now aged 27, Morissette has done most of her growing up in public and here she presents the musical evidence. Gone is the bile splattered anger and almost childish angst of 'Jagged Little Pill', in its place Alanis vents her inner demons in less overt ways. 'Hands Clean' and 'Flinch' examine the damage done by youthful relationships with predatory elder men but the anger has faded to worn regret. Whilst in stark contrast to 'You Oughta Know', 'That Particular Time' describes the collapse of a relationship without recriminations or blame. The Alanis of 2002 acknowledges her own failings as well as that of her feckless men, 'Narcissus' is as much about her own foolishness, "Why do I try to love / Try to love you when you really don?t want me to?" as it is about the idiot of the title. There is added musical depth too, the hazy distorted guitars and lilting chorus of 'Narcissus' hint at a definite acquaintance with the work of Leona Naess, whilst Beth Orten could easily appropriate the folky texture of closer 'Utopia'. There is an impressive breadth of material too, from the stomping rant of opener '21 Things...' to the bleak and barren ballads such as 'That Particular Time'. Even the albums most throw away moments, 'So Unsexy' and 'You Owe Me Nothing' possess sufficient poise and melodic bite to make fulfilling listening.
The album kicks off with a crashing guitar line and a throaty vocal, which serves to confirm that the ghost of 'Supposed...' has been firmly banished from the recording studio. '21 Things That I Want in a Lover' is the closest to old school Alanis present here. Full on and passionate, in most hands the volume of lyrics in the verse would overwhelm the listener but the unrelenting guitar roar keeps them in line, marrying them to a marching melody and leading into a neat low strung chorus. Alanis sets out her criteria for the ideal man, but hinting that she knows better; admitting "Not necessarily needs / But qualities that I prefer." The superb little twist in the middle eight and the sudden fade out on conclusion create a startling curtain raiser.
The distorted blend of fade in/out guitars and digitised rhythms that open 'Narcissus' meanwhile serve to demonstrate that Alanis is no longer in a musical rut. Although the track borrows heavily from Leona Naess' fantastic 'Charm Attack', Alanis manages to add a twist of originality in the unexpected melodic twists the track spins through. The unusual guitar work leads into a pleasant floaty vocal melody before solidifying into a neat hook in the bridge. The key surprise however, is saved for the sudden downward spiralling chorus, for which Alanis reserves the best of her venom "You go back to the women who will dance the dance / You go back to your friends who will lick your ass!" The hazy melody works wonderfully and given Ms Morrisette's usual tactic of going straight for the aural jugular is another hint of the maturity prevalent on the album.
The crucial evidence for Alanis' musical growth however is kept on the album's two pivotal tracks, 'At the Particular Time' and 'Flinch'. Never previously a great strength these two songs represent a textbook example of how to write and perform a strong ballad. 'At That Particular Time' despite its weak title is already making a strong case for my favourite song of the year (and its only June!). Beautifully paced and built on a bleak and sparse canvass of piano and subtle strings, Alanis sings with moving guilt, regret and elegant beauty. The contrast from the harsh screeching of 'You Oughta Know' could hardly be greater. The melody is gentle but memorable and moves seamlessly from verse to a stirring chorus before soaring into the middle eight that eventually crashes down in a wave of pathos and the repeated line "I'm sorry I lost myself." The lyric meanwhile represents an adult reflection on the end of a love affair rather then childish recrimination; she highlights her own mistakes as much as that of the former partner.
'Flinch' therefore provides both a contrast and coherence to 'That Particular Time'. Dealing with a similar subject matter, the bitterness and resentment of early Alanis is more clearly visible "What's it been / Half a decade? / It still hurts like it was four months ago" but tinged with strength and a desire to move on "Soon I'll grow up / And I won't even flinch at your name." Crucially the difference is in the music, constructed from just acoustic guitars and vocals, the songs whole outlook is different. Rather then screaming and looking for revenge, Morisette is now more human, hurt and still affected; with this approach she shows far more of her inner pain then her earlier spiky incarnation. These intriguing lyrical insights into Morisette's psyche are thankfully married to a dark but pretty melody, with a brooding verse and free flowing chorus which spirals into a tag line that is more pain then spite.
Thankfully however, Morisette has not lost her knack for penning a winning pop song either. Flyer single 'Hands Clean' hits all the right marks as a perfect piece of pop/rock, although its somewhat subdued chart success suggests the musical climate has moved on, since 'Jagged Little Pill'. The clever mix of the girlish acoustic verses, a tension building middle eight and a pile driving electric driven hook laden chorus works wonders and seems perfect FM radio material. Again Morisette has calmed the bile in the lyrics, letting the actions of her former lover speak for themselves. The bite is more in the music, with the contrast between the razor sharp acoustics in the verse and the pounding electrics of the chorus making the point more elegantly then a whole essay of poisoned prose. Add to this the lovely swirl of the middle eight, and you have one of the finest singles of this year to date (although admittedly the competition hasn't exactly been tough so far).
'Precious Illusions' is cut from the same cloth and seems a safe bet for release number two, but improves on the template by providing such a hook infested bridge which winds up the tension so efficiently that the explosion of the chorus is practically earth shattering. Again the acoustic guitars, which introduce the track, are as sharp as knives, whilst Morisette's deep-seated vocal hints at the volcanic eruption to come. The electronic percussion, which gradually kicks in underlines the tracks edginess, before the whole rhythm and mood alters on the bridge as Alanis' voice gradually rises until the thumping crescendo of the chorus is unleashed. The spite and anger which has been spread so thinly on other tracks is given free reign here, but acting as a contrast rather then the norm and complementing the music wonderfully it provides a delicious concoction.
'Surrendering' provides the final piece of this accessible trilogy, quick paced and instantly foot tapping in its syncopation and jarring guitar lines. The odd little flute line which opens the song, and the hint of sitars in the guitar mix give the track an original feel, whilst the chorus is once again text book stuff, with an adhesive melody and driving beat. The guitars pound away in the background in a particularly startling manner, always teetering on the edge of dominating the proceedings, but reigned back by the sheer power of the vocal melody.
'A Man' meanwhile is the albums darkest moment, where Alanis gives a wry look into what she sees as the male psyche, opting for a spot of first person empathy. Unsurprisingly its not a pretty sight, but acts as an interesting lyrical companion to 'You Oughta Know', "Been crucified by an enraged woman" being a notable illustration. The song is a slow paced and guitar heavy beast, with the melody a tub-thumping resilient beast and the guitars occasionally hinting at metal, rather then their usual more restrained selves.
The somewhat disposable 'So Unsexy' and 'You Owe Me Nothing' are the records weakest moments, although neither is completely without merit. 'So Unsexy' borrows 'Narcissus' hazy, almost out of tune guitar backdrop. The lyric is almost mocking in its self-loathing, dominated by self-pity whilst undoubtedly aware of the ridiculousness of its content. An above average chorus adds to a listenable package, although it's notable that the track was much improved in a stripped down acoustic live performance. 'You Owe Me Nothing' meanwhile builds neatly from ghostly keyboards and synthesised strings into an interesting melody on the verse but lets the game down with a somewhat dull chorus and the album's weakest lyric.
Far better is closing track 'Utopia' which adds one final contrast to Alanis' back catalogue. Built on a swirl of strings and acoustics, the song floats along with the albums prettiest vocal performance and a distinct tinge of folk to the chorus and structure. The displaced harmonies, which descend a second after each other on the chorus give the song an ethereal air, not a term one would usually associate with Morisette's work. The closing sea of sighing choral harmonies rounds off the record nicely, one final surprise on a record at times bursting with unexpected turns.
'Under Rug Swept' is a rich and rewarding record. It effortlessly retraces the very qualities which brought Alanis to widespread attention whilst updating her musical palette and toning down her more extreme lyrical tendencies. Crucially the winning melodic knack of her debut has been rediscovered, with some real gems as the result. How well Morisette will fair in today's somewhat different chart environment is unclear however, and the more mature outlook may disappoint those looking for a less considered dose of cathartic rage, but 'Under Rug Swept' comes recommended for those looking for a refreshing and yet familiar take on the guitar aided singer songwriter sound.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
I'm quite a fan of Alanis and haven't got round to buying this album yet, although I've heard a few from the net, which I was impressed with! And you are damn right, where the hell *has* Meredith Brooks gone? Excellent op, you sure have skill when it comes to writing album ops!
littlemissdrunk 26.06.2002 02:24
Brilliantly written op...but I can't say I completely agree with you :) My favourites have to be Flinch and So Unsexy. Its funny that you mention That Particular Time as being one of your favourites...as though I love the melody of it, I can't help finding the lyrics cheesy - it ruins it every time for me. But that's the great thing about her work...we can all take different things from it :D Nice to see a fellow fan :D Laura xxx
chunka 26.06.2002 01:57
Alanis is a genuine original, I love her music though I've nevr brought any of her albums! She has such a talent for writing, her music is great and her voice is amazing but her words go further! I'd like to buy one of her albums but unsure as which one to buy, could you suggest one for me? Cheers, Chunka!
With all the attention Alanis Morissette's career has garnered, it's startling to think ... more
that on the release of her third studio CD, she has yet to see her 28th birthday. Under Rug Swept finds Morissette in the producer's role, a position in which she s...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...