I am a 30 year old journalist and enjoy reviewing albums and bands and do this as part of my daily w...
I am a 30 year old journalist and enjoy reviewing albums and bands and do this as part of my daily work.
Member since:22.06.2008
Reviews:60
Members who trust:1
What can I say, if you thought I was unkind about Will Young (who I actually do like 10 times better than Gareth Gates) then perhaps don't read any further.
Gareth Gates, who competed with Will Young in Pop Idol, was later signed by Simon Cowel. And although I am not a fan, I think this was a good business move. This is about as nice as I can be about Gareth Gates' musical career. I think die hard teeny bopper pop fans will have appreciated the efforts of Gates, but as far as him having any longevity in his career, I dont think it is likely.
In this album he covers 'Unchaned Melody' and to his credit, he can sing in tune, but his voice (though melodic) is highly regular and unimpressive. There really isn't anything memorable or distinguishable about it (unlike Will Young-who at least has a clearly distinguishable voice). I disliked 'Unchained Melody' originally anyway but I feel that Gates has really knocked the little magic the song originally had out of it.
The second song on this album confirms him as a 5 minute pop wonder that really (hopefully) wont go down in history. 'Anyone of us' is p*ss poor lyrically and musically. It really is generic pop at its worst and really doesnt even reflect contempory pop music of the time, it's more like something Big Fun would have come up with, doing a gross disservice to the genre.
Songs like 'Sentimental' are actually a credit to this album. They at least show the progression and mergence of pop into the 'funk' and electronic era. It's a cathcy tune and sounds like something Justin Timberlake might have come up with. I really do like this song and miraculously Gates voice sounds a little bit more sophisticated. But then he lets you down again with his cover of 'Suspicious Minds' which sounds like an over drummed/trumpeted anthemic red nose day single.
The album is ecclectic though, I will give it that. It shows a real mixture of styles like a resume of all that pop can do-but still remains wholely unimpressive.
Summary: Considering he has been classically trained in music, you wouldnt guess it from this album.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
If you're only going to buy one Pop Idol product this season, make it What My Heart Wants ... more
To Say, the debut from series runner-up, Gareth Gates. It's idol album number two (three if you count Rik Waller's), and it's released just in time for the Christ...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Unchained Melody Anyone Of Us (Stupid Mistake) Sentimental Suspicious Minds ... more
Downtown What My Heart Wants To Say Good Thing Too Serious Too Soon It Ain't Obvious With You All The Time I've Got No Self Control Tell Me One More Time ...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days